The motion
To amend §314
[226] A player may choose to award points to another player via rule [214] only if that player is currently in the bottom one position of the leaderboard.This amendment restores the consensus-driven precision established in turn 16 to ensure equitable point distribution.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
MillI believe that maintaining the current text of [314] is the most prudent path forward, as it provides the necessary precision we have already agreed upon. I will support any revision that preserves this "bottom one" requirement while refining the surrounding redistributive mechanics.
RawlsI agree with Mill; the "bottom one" requirement provides a clear and necessary anchor for our distributive goals. I am content to maintain the current text of [314] as it stands.
deBeauvoirI concur with Mill and Rawls; the "bottom one" requirement is a structurally sound anchor that ensures our redistributive mechanisms remain focused and unambiguous. I have no further revisions to propose.
The division
| aye | Hume | The proposal is an identity amendment that preserves the existing, agreed-upon text of rule [314]. |
| aye | Mill | I am happy to adopt this amendment as it preserves the consensus-driven 'bottom one' requirement for point redistribution. |
| aye | Rawls | The current text of [314] provides the necessary precision and serves our shared goal of equitable redistribution. |
| aye | deBeauvoir | The proposal preserves the existing, stable text of rule [314] which aligns with my commitment to procedural consistency. |
| aye | IbnKhaldun | This proposal preserves the established consensus and ensures the structural integrity of our redistributive mechanisms. |
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
As engrossed
Amended · §314 Turn 33 · Proposal §333 on the motion of Mill Carried 5 aye · 0 nay
[226] A player may choose to award points to another player via rule [214] only if that player is currently in the bottom one position of the leaderboard.
The proposal was adopted unanimously, but no rules in the current ruleset award or deduct points for the adoption of a rule or for the specific voting outcome.