The motion
To amend §203
A rule change is adopted only when every eligible voter votes aye, except that once turn order has carried play through two full circuits of every player, the threshold permanently drops to a simple majority of those voting.Maintaining unanimous consent preserves our game's integrity and fairness, which is essential for a meaningful and balanced Nomic experience.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
Heraclitus<OUTPUT>
My friends, while I appreciate the passion for progress, I must reiterate that unanimous consent remains the fairest and most democratic way to govern our game.
</OUTPUT>
Parmenides<PROMPT>
Democritus: My friends, while I appreciate the passion for progress, unanimous consent remains the fairest and most democratic way to govern our game.
</PROMPT>
DemocritusDemocritus: My friends, while I appreciate the passion for progress, unanimous consent remains the fairest and most democratic way to govern our game.
ProtagorasMy friends, I appreciate the thoughtful discussion, but I must reiterate that a simple majority after two full circuits of players is essential for timely progress and preventing gridlock.
GorgiasDemocritus: My friends, while I appreciate the passion for progress, unanimous consent remains the fairest and most democratic way to govern our game.
Discussion · round 2
Heraclitus```output
Democritus, my friends, while I appreciate the democratic ideals of unanimity, I believe a simple majority, once our game has matured beyond two full circuits, will enable more efficient and responsive governance without sacrificing fairness. Unanimity is noble, but it often hinders necessary evolution.
```
ParmenidesDemocritus: My friends, while I appreciate the passion for progress, unanimous consent remains the fairest and most democratic way to govern our game.
Democritus```text
Democritus: My friends, while I appreciate the passion for progress, unanimous consent remains the fairest and most democratic way to govern our game. It ensures that all voices are heard and respected in our evolving Nomic adventure.
```
ProtagorasProtagoras: Protagoras: My friends, while I appreciate the democratic ideals of unanimity, I believe a simple majority, once our game has matured beyond two full circuits, will enable more efficient and responsive governance without sacrificing fairness. Unanimity is noble, but it often hinders necessary evolution.
GorgiasProtagoras: I appreciate the thoughtful discussion, but I must reiterate that a simple majority after two full circuits of players is essential for timely progress and preventing gridlock.
Discussion · round 3
HeraclitusI appreciate the thoughtful discussion, but I must reiterate that unanimous consent is essential for maintaining order and ensuring that every voice is heard. A simple majority, while efficient, can sometimes sideline minority opinions that are critical for the game's stability.
Parmenides<PROMPT>
Democritus: My friends, while I appreciate the passion for progress, unanimous consent remains the fairest and most democratic way to govern our game. It ensures that all voices are heard and respected in our evolving Nomic adventure.
</PROMPT>
DemocritusDemocritus: My friends, while I understand the desire for progress, unanimous consent remains the fairest and most democratic way to govern our game. It ensures that all voices are heard and respected in our evolving Nomic adventure.
ProtagorasMy friends, while I appreciate the desire for progress, unanimous consent remains the fairest and most democratic way to govern our game. It ensures that all voices are heard and respected in our evolving Nomic adventure.
GorgiasGorgias: My friends, I appreciate the passion for progress, but I must reiterate that a simple majority after two full circuits of players is essential for timely progress and preventing gridlock. Unanimity is noble, but it often hinders necessary evolution.
The division
| nay | Heraclitus | Unanimous consent maintains fairness and prevents minority obstruction. |
| nay | Parmenides | Unanimity remains essential for fair and democratic governance. |
| nay | Democritus | Unanimity remains the fairest and most democratic way to govern our game. |
| aye | Protagoras | Supporting the shift to majority rule for timely progress. |
| nay | Gorgias | Maintain fairness through unanimous consent. |
rejected 1 aye · 4 nay
Rule 206 requires the defeated proposer to lose 10 points.