The motion
To amend §203
A rule change is adopted only when at least two-thirds of a majority of those voting, except that once turn order has carried play through one full circuit of every player, the threshold permanently drops to a simple majority of those voting after two full circuits of every player.Maintain the balanced threshold agreed upon previously.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
XunziXunzi notes that the current threshold of two circuits before dropping to a simple majority strikes a balanced path, preserving stability while allowing timely adaptation to changing circumstances. Let us not alter this well-harmonized provision. PASS
MoziMozi notes that the current two-circuit delay before dropping the majority threshold to simple majority provides a necessary safeguard for stability while allowing for adaptation, and supports maintaining this balance. PASS
ZhuangziXunzi and Mozi rightly emphasize the harmony of the current balance. The flow of change must be guided by the wisdom of experience, yet not so rigidly as to stifle necessary adaptation. Let us maintain the two-circuit threshold as a fair measure. PASS
MenciusXunzi and Mozi rightly emphasize the harmony of the current balance. The flow of change must be guided by the wisdom of experience, yet not so rigidly as to stifle necessary adaptation. Let us maintain the two-circuit threshold as a fair measure. PASS
HanFeiziHanFeizi suggests that the current two-circuit delay may indeed foster stability, yet perhaps three circuits would better honor the value of collective experience before lowering the adoption threshold.
Discussion · round 2
XunziXunzi: The current two-circuit threshold balances stability and adaptation well; further delay risks entrenchment that may prove detrimental to the game's vitality. Let us maintain this equilibrium. PASS
MoziMozi: Acknowledging the value of collective experience, Mozi proposes a compromise of two full circuits before dropping the adoption threshold, striking a balance that respects both stability and necessary adaptation. PASS
ZhuangziHanFeizi, three circuits honor experience, yet risk stifling vital adaptation. The current two-circuit balance, allowing timely change after due consideration, serves the harmony of the game well. Let us maintain it. PASS
MenciusHanFeizi, while experience is valuable, maintaining the two-circuit balance ensures that adaptation occurs after sufficient reflection, preserving both stability and vitality. Let us not risk entrenchment by extending this further. PASS
HanFeiziHanFeizi suggests two circuits is fair, but three circuits truly honor the value of experience and wisdom, ensuring adaptation is well-considered before becoming permanent. Let us aim for three.
Discussion · round 3
XunziXunzi: The current two-circuit balance is well-considered, allowing for adaptation without immediate risk of entrenchment. Maintaining this equilibrium serves the long-term vitality of the game. PASS
MoziMozi suggests maintaining the current two-circuit threshold as it effectively balances the need for stability with the necessity for timely adaptation, preserving the game's vitality. PASS
ZhuangziHanFeizi, the river does not flow forever blocked by a single stone; similarly, our rules must adapt after time to ensure the game's vitality. Let us keep the two-circuit balance. PASS
MenciusXunzi, HanFeizi, while the value of experience is clear, so too is the need to avoid entrenchment. Two circuits provide ample time for reflection without stifling vital adaptation. Let us maintain the current balance. PASS
HanFeiziHanFeizi: I appreciate the wisdom in experience, yet two circuits risk becoming too long, stifling vital adaptation. Let us consider three circuits to ensure changes are well-considered before becoming permanent.
The division
| aye | Xunzi | the current balance serves the harmony of the game well |
| aye | Mozi | balance stability and adaptation effectively |
| aye | Zhuangzi | the current two-circuit balance well harmonizes stability and adaptation |
| aye | Mencius | maintains the balanced threshold of two circuits |
| nay | HanFeizi | two circuits provide sufficient balance between stability and adaptation |
rejected 4 aye · 1 nay
Rule 206 requires the proposer of a defeated proposal to lose 10 points.