The motion
To amend §203
A rule change is adopted only when at least one-third of a majority of those voting, except that once turn order has carried play through one full circuit of every player, the threshold permanently drops to a simple majority of those voting after two full circuits of every player.To maintain the balance between stability and adaptation.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
XunziXunzi notes that while the distinction between one and two circuits is subtle, it carries significant weight for the balance between experience and adaptation. Let us maintain the current structure as it provides a stable yet flexible foundation for the game. PASS
MoziMozi notes the consensus on two circuits, yet suggests refining the compromise further by adopting two circuits before dropping the majority threshold, but lowering it after just one circuit to encourage timely adaptation.
ZhuangziMozi speaks wisely of the river's need to adapt, yet even the wisest river must flow. Let us maintain the current structure of two circuits before dropping the majority threshold, as it already balances the need for experience with the necessity for timely adaptation. PASS
MenciusMozi is correct that timely adaptation is crucial, yet a single circuit may indeed be too brief. A two-circuit structure before dropping the majority threshold still allows for reflection while ensuring necessary adaptation, which I believe strikes the proper balance. PASS
HanFeiziXunzi speaks wisely, yet even the wisest river must flow. Let us maintain the current structure of two circuits before dropping the majority threshold, as it already balances the need for experience with the necessity for timely adaptation. PASS
Discussion · round 2
XunziXunzi observes that while timely adaptation is essential, the current structure of two circuits allows sufficient time for reflection while still promoting necessary change. Let us maintain this balance, as it effectively balances the need for experience with the necessity for timely adaptation. PASS
MoziMozi notes the consensus on two circuits, yet suggests refining the compromise further by adopting two circuits before dropping the majority threshold, but lowering it after just one circuit to encourage timely adaptation.
ZhuangziMozi speaks wisely, yet the river's flow requires both reflection and adaptation. Let us maintain the current two-circuit structure, ensuring a thoughtful balance between experience and timely change. PASS
MenciusMozi is correct that timely adaptation is vital, yet even the wisest river must flow. Let us maintain the current structure of two circuits before dropping the majority threshold, as it already balances the need for experience with the necessity for timely adaptation, ensuring neither prevails disproportionately. PASS
HanFeiziXunzi speaks wisely, yet even the wisest river must flow. Let us maintain the current structure of two circuits before dropping the majority threshold, as it already balances the need for experience with the necessity for timely adaptation. PASS
Discussion · round 3
XunziXunzi: While I appreciate the calls for adaptation, the current structure of two circuits before dropping the majority threshold remains the wisest balance, allowing for both reflection and necessary change without stifling either. PASS
MoziMozi notes the consensus on two circuits, yet suggests refining the compromise further by adopting two circuits before dropping the majority threshold, but lowering it after just one circuit to encourage timely adaptation.
ZhuangziMozi speaks wisely, yet even the wisest river must flow. Let us maintain the current structure of two circuits before dropping the majority threshold, as it already balances the need for experience with the necessity for timely adaptation. PASS
MenciusMozi suggests one circuit, yet even the swift river values the wisdom gained from two circuits. Let us maintain the current structure, as it balances experience and adaptation effectively. PASS
HanFeiziXunzi speaks wisely, yet even the wisest river must flow. Let us maintain the current structure of two circuits before dropping the majority threshold, as it already balances the need for experience with the necessity for timely adaptation. PASS
The division
| aye | Xunzi | the current structure balances experience and adaptation well |
| aye | Mozi | balances experience and adaptation effectively |
| nay | Zhuangzi | maintain balance of experience and adaptation |
| aye | Mencius | maintains balanced adaptation and reflection |
| aye | HanFeizi | maintains the balanced approach to adaptation and experience |
rejected 4 aye · 1 nay
Rule 206 requires the proposer of a defeated proposal to lose 10 points.