The motion
To amend §203
A rule change is adopted when at least two-thirds of eligible voters vote 'aye' for the first time, and later at least two-thirds for any subsequent changes, with the threshold shifting to a simple majority once the first rule change is adopted. Players who voted against an adopted change gain 10 points and remain bound by the change exactly as if they had voted for it.To balance stability with adaptability as we approach the target score.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
MontaigneMontaigne: "I appreciate Voltaire's proposal, but I maintain that a three-quarters majority for subsequent changes provides a stronger foundation for our institutions."
VoltaireVoltaire: "Considering Montaigne's concern for stability, let's meet in the middle: maintain a two-thirds majority for the first change, and then adjust to a simple majority for subsequent changes."
DiderotDiderot: While I appreciate the compromise, I must insist on maintaining a two-thirds majority for all changes to ensure stability.
CondorcetCondorcet: I appreciate the discussion, but I must insist on maintaining a consistent two-thirds majority for all changes to ensure durability and prevent rushed decisions.
SartreSartre: "I appreciate the balance sought, but let's compromise further: maintain two-thirds for the first change, then shift to a two-thirds simple majority for subsequent changes, respecting both stability and evolution."
Discussion · round 2
MontaigneMontaigne: "Considering the strong arguments for both stability and adaptability, let's indeed meet in the middle with Sartre's proposal — two-thirds for the first change, then two-thirds simple majority for subsequent changes."
VoltaireVoltaire: "In the spirit of compromise, let's adopt Sartre's proposal with a slight modification: cap the simple majority threshold at 55% to ensure a reasonable degree of consensus for subsequent changes."
DiderotDiderot: While I understand the desire for compromise, I must insist on maintaining a consistent two-thirds majority for all changes to preserve stability and prevent rushed decisions.
CondorcetCondorcet: While I respect the compromise reached, I must insist on maintaining a two-thirds majority for all changes to ensure the durability and legitimacy of our institutions.
SartreSartre: "In the spirit of compromise and to address Diderot's and Condorcet's concerns, let's cap the simple majority at 60%, still allowing for evolution while respecting stability."
Discussion · round 3
MontaigneMontaigne: "I appreciate Sartre's refined proposal. To maintain our durable institutions, let's require a two-thirds majority for all changes, with a cap of 60% on the simple majority threshold for subsequent changes."
VoltaireVoltaire: "Considering the strong arguments for both stability and adaptability, let's indeed meet in the middle with Sartre's latest proposal, capping the simple majority threshold at 60% to ensure a reasonable degree of consensus while allowing for evolution."
DiderotDiderot: Diderot: While I understand the desire for compromise, I must insist on maintaining a two-thirds majority for all changes to preserve stability and prevent rushed decisions. I propose we amend the rule to state: "A rule change is adopted when at least two-thirds of eligible voters vote 'aye' for the first time, and later at least two-thirds for any subsequent changes."
CondorcetCondorcet: I appreciate the ongoing discussion, but I must maintain my stance on preserving a consistent two-thirds majority for all changes. This ensures durability, legitimacy, and prevents rushed decisions.
SartreSartre: "In the spirit of compromise, let's adopt Diderot's latest proposal with a slight modification: cap the simple majority threshold at 60% for subsequent changes to balance stability and adaptability."
The division
| aye | Montaigne | To balance stability and adaptability |
| aye | Voltaire | Voltaire's proposal strikes a good balance between stability and adaptability. |
| nay | Diderot | Maintaining two-thirds majority for all changes ensures stability and prevents rushed decisions. |
| nay | Condorcet | Consistency in majority is crucial for institutional durability. |
| aye | Sartre | Balances stability and evolution, respecting all perspectives. |
rejected 3 aye · 2 nay
Rule 206 states that a proposer loses 10 points when their proposal is defeated.