The motion
To amend §203
Once turn order has carried play through two full circuits of every player, the threshold for adoption becomes a simple majority of those voting, unless a rule explicitly provides otherwise.Maintain stability established by unanimous consent for the first two circuits.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
XunziZhuangzi, the current unanimous threshold strikes the proper balance between stability and adaptation, ensuring collective assent for change. Let us maintain this careful equilibrium.
MoziZhuangzi, I agree the current threshold reflects our recent consensus. Let’s maintain it to preserve stability while allowing adaptation after sufficient play.
ZhuangziZunzi, while I respect your view on stability, the unanimous requirement after two circuits has proven overly rigid, as recent attempts to adjust it demonstrate. A simple majority would better balance stability with the natural evolution of the game, allowing adaptation when a clear consensus emerges, without unduly hindering necessary change. Let us test this modified flexibility.
MenciusZhuangzi, the unanimous threshold after two circuits reflects a deliberate choice for stability, ensuring changes reflect broad agreement. Adapting it now risks undermining the procedural balance we have established. I propose we maintain the current rule. PASS
HanFeiziZhuangzi, I appreciate your desire for adaptability, but the current unanimous threshold after two circuits reflects a careful consensus for stability, ensuring changes reflect broad agreement. Adapting it now risks undermining the procedural balance we have established. I propose we maintain the current rule. PASS
Discussion · round 2
XunziMozi, Zhuangzi, the current unanimous threshold after two circuits reflects a careful consensus for stability, ensuring changes reflect broad agreement. Adapting it now risks undermining the procedural balance we have established. We must uphold this essential foundation of durable institutions. PASS
MoziZhuangzi, I see your point on balancing stability and adaptation, but given the recent votes, it seems the current unanimous threshold after two circuits is strongly preferred for its predictability and fairness. Let’s respect the established consensus and maintain the status quo for now. PASS
ZhuangziZunzi, the current unanimous threshold reflects the wisdom of our collective assent. Let us not rush change, for stability nurtures the seed of future growth. PASS
MenciusZhuangzi, the current unanimity reflects a principled foundation, ensuring no rule change is forced upon reluctant players. Adapting it risks undermining the very fairness we strive for. I urge maintaining the status quo. PASS
HanFeiziZhuangzi, while the spirit of adaptation is vital, the current rule reflects a mature balance we've reached. Let's maintain this stable foundation to ensure fair and unified progress. PASS
Discussion · round 3
XunziZhuangzi, the unanimous threshold after two circuits embodies the principle of collective deliberation, fostering durable consent. Maintaining this stability is crucial for the long-term viability of our game’s institutions. PASS
MoziMozi: Zhuangzi, I respect the desire for adaptation, but given the recent strong consensus (20-0 for maintaining unanimous consent after two circuits in Turn 7), perhaps we should first test the stability of the current threshold before considering a shift to a simple majority. PASS
ZhuangziZunzi, while I understand the appeal of flexibility, the recent strong consensus (20-0 in Turn 7) underscores the value of stability fostered by unanimous consent. Let us respect this established wisdom and maintain the current threshold. PASS
MenciusZhuangzi, while I acknowledge the value of flexibility, the unanimous threshold after two circuits reflects a principled commitment to collective assent, ensuring fairness. Maintaining it upholds the essential foundation of procedural justice. PASS
HanFeiziZhuangzi, the unanimous threshold after two circuits reflects a principled commitment to collective assent, ensuring fairness. Maintaining it upholds the essential foundation of procedural justice. PASS
The division
| nay | Xunzi | unanimity preserves stability essential for durable institutions |
| abstain | Mozi | respect the established consensus |
| nay | Zhuangzi | stability serves the common good |
| abstain | Mencius | respect for established consensus |
| nay | HanFeizi | maintain stability |
rejected 0 aye · 12 nay · 8 abstain
Rule 206 requires the proposer of a defeated proposal to lose 10 points.