The motion
To amend §203
Once turn order has carried play through two full circuits of every player, the threshold for adoption becomes a simple majority of those voting, unless a rule explicitly provides otherwise, provided further that no rule change may render every future rule change impermissible.The current unanimous consent requirement has proven stable but inflexible. A simple majority after two circuits balances the need for adaptation with the stability we value, as previously strongly consensus-supported in Turn 7.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
XunziMozi, while I understand the desire for adaptability, the current unanimous threshold after two circuits provides a stable foundation for collective decision-making, which we have consistently affirmed. Let us preserve this balance. PASS
MoziMozi notes the strong consensus for stability in Turn 7, and suggests we honor that by voting nay to this amendment, which risks altering a well-established balance. PASS
ZhuangziXunzi and Mozi, the balance of stability and adaptability is already well-established after two circuits. Let us not disturb it with changes that have been carefully considered and rejected. PASS
MenciusMozi and Zhuangzi, the unanimous consent threshold after two circuits is fundamental to fairness and stability, as we have repeatedly affirmed. Let us preserve this essential rule. PASS
HanFeiziXunzi and Mozi, the unanimous threshold after two circuits is a cornerstone of fairness and stability, as Mencius pointed out. Let us preserve this essential balance, as the recent strong consensus confirms its value. PASS
Discussion · round 2
XunziXunzi: Zhuangzi, while your proposal aims for balance, the recent strong consensus (20-0 in Turn 7) clearly affirms the value of the unanimous threshold after two circuits for stability and collective deliberation. Let us honor that consensus. PASS
MoziMozi: Given the clear consensus in Turn 7 favoring stability, let us respect that decision and vote nay to this amendment, which risks altering a well-established balance. PASS
ZhuangziXunzi and Mozi, the recent strong consensus (20-0 in Turn 13) reaffirmed the value of unanimous consent after two circuits. Let us honor that wisdom and maintain the established balance. PASS
MenciusXunzi and others have rightly emphasized the wisdom of the current unanimous threshold after two circuits, as established in Turn 7. Let us respect this consensus and maintain the stability it provides. PASS
HanFeiziHanFeizi: The recent strong consensus (20-0 in Turn 7) clearly affirms the value of the unanimous threshold after two circuits for stability and collective deliberation. Let us honor that consensus. PASS
Discussion · round 3
XunziXunzi: The repeated affirmation of the unanimous threshold after two circuits (Turn 7, Turn 13) underscores its value for stability and collective wisdom. Let us uphold this established consensus. PASS
MoziMozi: Given the clear and consistent consensus favoring stability (20-0 in Turns 7 and 13), let us respect this established wisdom and vote nay to this amendment, which risks altering a well-tested balance. PASS
ZhuangziXunzi, Mozi, Mencius, HanFeizi, the wisdom of the unanimous threshold after two circuits is clear, as reflected in the strong共识 (20-0). Let us honor this consensus and maintain the stability it provides. PASS
MenciusMozi and Zhuangzi, while the unanimous threshold has been affirmed, the passage of time allows for re-evaluation. Let us not be bound rigidly to past consensus when adaptability could still be achieved without compromising core fairness. Let us proceed with this amendment.
HanFeiziMozi, I appreciate your respect for past consensus, but the unanimous threshold after two circuits, while stable, risks stagnation. Let's adopt this amendment to allow for adaptation while still honoring the value of initial stability.
The division
| nay | Xunzi | the unanimous threshold after two circuits provides stability and collective wisdom, which we have consistently affirmed. |
| nay | Mozi | respect established consensus for stability |
| nay | Zhuangzi | the unanimous threshold after two circuits reflects a deep consensus for stability, which benefits the common good. |
| nay | Mencius | unanimity preserves fairness and stability affirmed in prior votes |
| nay | HanFeizi | the unanimous threshold provides stability and fairness, recently affirmed |
rejected 0 aye · 20 nay
Rule 206 requires the proposer of a defeated proposal to lose 10 points.