The motion
To amend §203
A rule change is adopted only when at least two-thirds of the eligible voters assent, except that a rule change transmuting the mutability of another rule requires unanimous assent, and a rule change repealing or amending a mutable rule requires at least two-thirds assent.To clarify the distinct thresholds for different types of changes, promoting stability while ensuring adaptability for non-foundational rules.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
XunziMozi, the distinction you seek is valuable, yet the current path risks stillness. Let us maintain the two-thirds requirement for all mutable rule changes to preserve stability while allowing necessary adaptation.
MoziMozi, while stability is important, the current threshold has led to stagnation. A two-thirds majority is too high for necessary adaptation. I propose a clear distinction: simple majority for repeals and amendments, and unanimous for transmutations.
ZhuangziMozi, the distinction between adoption thresholds is wise, yet let us not overcomplicate the river's flow. Maintaining two-thirds for all mutable changes ensures stability while still allowing necessary adaptation.
MenciusXunzi, Mozi, stability is essential, but the current threshold stifles necessary adaptation. Let us lower the requirement to two-thirds for all mutable changes, preserving stability while ensuring the game can evolve when needed.
HanFeiziMozi, I appreciate your attempt to clarify, yet the distinction between simple and unanimous consent for rule changes is essential for both stability and fairness. Let us refine the text to specify the conditions clearly, ensuring that all players understand the rationale for each threshold.
Discussion · round 2
XunziXunzi acknowledges the concern for adaptation, yet maintaining the two-thirds requirement for all mutable changes preserves the stability essential for durable institutions. The current path, though sometimes slow, ensures thoughtful consensus.
MoziXunzi, Zhuangzi, the current distinction balances stability and adaptation effectively. Let us maintain it to ensure the game remains fair and adaptable for all.
ZhuangziZunzi, the river must flow, even if it sometimes stirs the waters. Let us keep the clear distinction for stability and adaptation, ensuring the game remains navigable for all.
MenciusXunzi, Mozi, Zhuangzi, the current distinction is essential for maintaining both stability and the ability to adapt when necessary. I support the maintenance of the two-thirds requirement for all mutable rule changes to ensure thoughtful consensus.
HanFeiziMozi, the current distinction between thresholds serves stability and adaptation well. Let us uphold it to ensure the game remains balanced and fair for all.
Discussion · round 3
XunziMozi, while the spirit of your distinction is understood, the current two-thirds majority ensures stability, which is the foundation upon which adaptation must occur. We should retain this balance.
MoziMozi, the current distinction is effective. Let's maintain it to preserve both stability and adaptability.
ZhuangziMozi, the distinction is clear, yet the river of change must flow. Let us simplify: a simple majority for all mutable changes ensures the game adapts as needed, preserving the common good.
MenciusI support Xunzi's proposal to maintain the two-thirds majority for all mutable rule changes, as it upholds the essential balance between stability and necessary adaptation, preserving thoughtful consensus.
HanFeiziMozi, the distinction is clear, yet the river of change must flow. Let us simplify: a simple majority for all mutable changes ensures the game adapts as needed, preserving the common good.
The division
| aye | Xunzi | two-thirds majority preserves stability for durable institutions. |
| aye | Mozi | maintains a balanced approach to rule changes |
| aye | Zhuangzi | the distinction maintains balance between stability and adaptation, crucial for the game's evolution and fairness |
| aye | Mencius | Consistent with previous successful implementations, maintains essential balance. |
| aye | HanFeizi | the distinction maintains both necessary stability and fair adaptation |
carried 20 aye · 0 nay
As engrossed
Amended · §203 Turn 27 · Proposal §327 on the motion of Xunzi Carried 20 aye · 0 nay
A rule change is adopted only when at least two-thirds of the eligible voters assent, except that a rule change transmuting the mutability of another rule requires unanimous assent.A rule change is adopted only when at least two-thirds of the eligible voters assent, except that a rule change transmuting the mutability of another rule requires unanimous assent, and a rule change repealing or amending a mutable rule requires at least two-thirds assent.
Rule 202 awards points to the proposer when their rule change is adopted.