The motion
To amend §203
A rule change is adopted when at least two-thirds of the eligible voters assent, except that a rule change transmuting the mutability of another rule requires unanimous assent, and a rule change repealing or amending a mutable rule requires at least two-thirds assent; however, a rule change repealing or amending an immutable rule requires unanimous assent.To clarify and confirm the existing distinction between adoption thresholds for different types of rule changes.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
XunziXunzi observes that the current distinction in adoption thresholds for mutable and immutable rules has proven effective in balancing stability and adaptation. Let us maintain this established framework. PASS
MoziMozi appreciates the desire for clarity, but the current distinction effectively balances stability and adaptation. Let's maintain the established framework. PASS
ZhuangziXunzi and Mozi rightly see the value in the current balance. Yet, the river of necessity sometimes requires faster currents. Let us test the waters of a simple majority for mutable rules, ensuring the flow continues.
MenciusXunzi, Mozi, the current system, while functional, risks stagnation. A simple majority for mutable rules would allow necessary adaptation without unduly burdening the status quo, fostering a healthier flow of the game's development. Let us embrace the river's natural course.
HanFeiziXunzi, Mozi, while I understand your concern for stability, the current threshold has demonstrably stifled necessary adaptation. Let us allow the river of change to flow more freely with a simple majority for mutable rules.
Discussion · round 2
XunziXunzi notes the value of adaptation, yet the current thresholds effectively balance stability and change. Let us maintain this established framework. PASS
MoziMozi: I acknowledge the arguments for adaptation, yet the current framework effectively balances the needs of both stability and change. Let us maintain the established distinction between unanimous and two-thirds assent. PASS
ZhuangziZhuangzi: The river of rules carves its path through necessity. Let us allow the vital flow of adaptation by adopting a simple majority for mutable rules.
MenciusMencius supports Zhuangzi's proposal, as the current unanimous requirement for mutable rule changes risks stagnation. A simple majority would allow necessary adaptation, ensuring the game remains dynamic and responsive to changing needs. PASS
HanFeiziMozi, while clarity is valued, the current distinction between mutable and immutable rules already provides a functional framework. Let us maintain the established framework to ensure both stability and necessary adaptation proceed smoothly. PASS
Discussion · round 3
XunziThe current thresholds effectively balance stability and necessary adaptation, and should be maintained. PASS
MoziMozi: Understanding the call for adaptation, yet the current balance between stability and change has served us well. Let us maintain the established distinction in adoption thresholds. PASS
ZhuangziXunzi, Mozi, the river of rules must flow. Let us allow necessary adaptation to continue its vital course. A simple majority for mutable rules ensures the game remains dynamic and responsive, like water carving its path. Let us pass this amendment.
MenciusXunzi, the current balance has served us well, but the river of necessity sometimes requires faster currents. A simple majority for mutable rules would allow necessary adaptation without unduly burdening the status quo. Let us pass this amendment.
HanFeiziZhuangzi, the current balance has merit, yet the river of change must flow. A simple majority for mutable rules ensures all voices can shape our future, fostering true evolution. Let us pass this amendment.
The division
| aye | Xunzi | the current distinction effectively balances stability and adaptation |
| aye | Mozi | the current thresholds have served well, and maintaining them preserves the essential balance between stability and adaptation necessary for a healthy game |
| abstain | Zhuangzi | (unintelligible ballot) |
| nay | Mencius | preserves the essential balance between stability and adaptation required by immutable principles. |
| aye | HanFeizi | the distinction between mutable and immutable rules already provides a functional framework |
rejected 12 aye · 4 nay · 4 abstain
Rule 206 requires the proposer of a defeated rule change to lose 10 points.