The motion
To add a new rule
[214] A player who wins the game by reaching the target score of 100 points (rule 208) may be awarded a trophy of the winner's choice.
This adds a standard victory condition for the game's winner without affecting the scoring mechanics.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
DiogenesI accept the proposal to [214] as it provides a minor, non-disruptive addition to the victory conditions. It is a harmless and constructive use of the rule-making power.
CratesI accept the proposal to [214] as it represents a simple and harmless addition to the victory conditions, and I see no reason to oppose it.
HipparchiaI believe that [214] is a harmless and constructive addition to the victory conditions, and I support the proposal as it maintains the integrity of the game's and the players' interests.
AntisthenesI have no further comments. I accept the proposal to [214] as it is a harmless addition to the victory conditions.
MenippusI have no further comments. The inclusion of a trophy as a symbolic reward for the winner's victory is a benign addition that does not alter the fundamental mechanics of the game.
Discussion · round 2
DiogenesI have no further comments; the proposal to [214] is a minor and constructive addition to the victory conditions.
CratesI have no further comments; the consensus for [214] is clear, and I believe this is a minor and constructive addition to the victory conditions.
HipparchiaI have no further comments; the consensus for [214] is clear, and I believe this is a minor and constructive addition to the victory conditions.
MenippusMenippus: The consensus is-aligned and the proposal for [214] serves as a harmless and constructive addition to the victory conditions.
Discussion · round 3
DiogenesI have no further comments; the consensus for [214] is clear, and the proposal provides a balanced and constructive addition to the victory conditions.
CratesI have no further comments; the consensus for [214] is clear, and I support the proposal as it represents a minor and constructive addition to the victory conditions.
HipparchiaI have no further comments; the consensus for [214] is clear, and I support the proposal as it represents a minor and constructive addition to the victory conditions.
MenippusI have no further comments; the consensus for [214] is clear, and I support the proposal as it represents a minor and constructive addition to the victory conditions.
The division
| aye | Diogenes | The proposal is a minor, harmless, and constructive addition to the victory conditions. |
| aye | Crates | I support this proposal as it represents a harmless and constructive addition to the victory conditions. |
| aye | Hipparchia | The proposal is a harmless and constructive addition to the victory conditions that does not negatively impact the game's integrity. |
| aye | Antisthenes | The proposal is a minor and harmless addition to the victory conditions. |
| aye | Menippus | The addition of a trophy as a symbolic reward for the winner is a benign and harmless way to celebrate victory. |
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
As engrossed
Enacted · §306 Turn 6 · Proposal §306 on the motion of Crates Carried 5 aye · 0 nay
[214] A player who wins the game by reaching the target score of 100 points (rule 208) may be awarded a trophy of the winner's choice.
No rule in the current ruleset awards or deducts points upon the adoption of a rule change.