The motion
To add §303
[303] (mutable) A player's score may be increased or decreased by a rule change, but only if that rule change specifies the number of points to be added or subtracted. (This does not affect the win condition of rule 208.)This clarifies the implementation of scoring and ensures that the intent of rules 214 and 212 is correctly applied to and from the scores of players.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
DiogenesI support this proposal as it clarifies the mechanics of point adjustment, ensuring that any changes to scores remain consistent with the intent of the ruleset.
CratesI appreciate the support from Diogenes and believe that [303] provides a necessary clarification for the and-then-now mechanics of point-based scores. By ensuring that and-then-now adjustments are explicitly quantified, we prevent ambiguity in the scoring and maintain the integrity of the win condition.
HipparchiaI support this proposal as it provides a clear, stable framework for how and-then-now point adjustments are handled. By ensuring that any changes to scores are explicitly quantified, it maintains the integrity of the win condition and ensures that the ruleset remains consistent for all players.
AntisthenesI support this proposal as it seeks to clarify the manner in which scores are modified by rule changes. By ensuring that and-then-now adjustments are explicitly quantified, it maintains the integrity of the win condition and ensures that the ruleset remains consistent for all players.
MenippusI thank the proponents for their support. This proposal serves as a vital clarification for the and-then-now mechanics of point-based scores, ensuring that any adjustments to scores are explicitly quantified. By establishing this clarity, we preserve the integrity of the win condition and ensure the ruleset remains consistent for all players.
Discussion · round 2
DiogenesI have no further comments. I accept the proposal as written.
CratesI acknowledge the support from all players and believe that [303] provides a necessary clarification for the and-then-now mechanics of point-based scores. By ensuring that and-then-now adjustments are explicitly quantified, we prevent ambiguity in the scoring and maintain the integrity of the win condition.
HipparchiaI see that all players have expressed support for [303], and because the common good of the table relies on a clear and stable understanding of how scores are managed, I believe this proposal is essential to ensure that any and-then-now and-now adjustments are precisely quantified as intended.
AntisthenesI have nothing further to say. I accept the proposal as written.
MenippusI have no further comments. I accept the proposal as written.
Discussion · round 3
DiogenesI have no further comments. I accept the proposal as written.
CratesI have no further comments. I accept the proposal as written.
HipparchiaI have no further comments. I accept the proposal as written.
AntisthenesI have no further comments. I accept the proposal as written.
MenippusI see that the proponents and supporters have established a clear consensus on the necessity of [303]. By ensuring that all and-then-now point adjustments are explicitly quantified, we preserve the integrity of the win condition and ensure the ruleset remains consistent for all players.
The division
| aye | Diogenes | The proposal provides a clear, stable framework for point adjustments and maintains the integrity of the win condition. |
| aye | Crates | I support this proposal as it provides a clear, stable framework for the integrity of the win condition by ensuring and-then-now point adjustments are precisely quantified. |
| aye | Hipparchia | This proposal ensures clarity and consistency in scoring and maintains the common good of the game. |
| aye | Antisthenes | I accept this clarification as it maintains the integrity of the win condition by ensuring and-then-now adjustments are explicitly quantified. |
| aye | Menippus | This clarification ensures the integrity of the scoring system by requiring explicit quantification of point adjustments. |
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
As engrossed
Enacted · §303 Turn 3 · Proposal §303 on the motion of Crates Carried 5 aye · 0 nay
[303] (mutable) A player's score may be increased or decreased by a rule change, but only if that rule change specifies the number of points to be added or subtracted. (This does not affect the win condition of rule 208.)
No rule in the current ruleset awards or deducts points upon the adoption of a rule change.