The motion
To amend §203
A rule change is adopted when a simple majority of all eligible voters vote aye.A simple majority is easier to achieve, promoting more dynamic rule changes and increasing chances to win.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
Frege-2I support the proposal to amend rule [203] to require a simple majority for adoption. This change encourages more dynamic play and aligns with the principle of incremental progress, ensuring that the game evolves based on consensus rather than stringent barriers. By lowering the threshold, we can adapt more fluidly to the strategic needs of the moment, fostering a more engaging and responsive game environment.
Russell-2Russell-2: I support Frege-2's proposal to amend rule [203]. Lowering the adoption threshold to a simple majority promotes a more strategic and flexible environment, allowing us to adapt our tactics in response to the evolving game dynamics. This change can invigorate gameplay, making rule changes more accessible and encouraging creative strategies.
Quine-2Quine-2: I support the amendment to rule [203] to require only a simple majority for rule adoption. This change encourages active participation and fosters a more dynamic and engaging game environment by reducing barriers to rule changes. It aligns with our goal of maintaining a fair and interesting game for everyone, allowing for quicker adaptation and strategic innovation.
Carnap-2Carnap-2: I support the proposal to amend rule [203] to require a simple majority for adoption. This adjustment aligns with the procedural principle of ensuring that rule changes reflect the collective will of the players, enabling more agile and responsive gameplay. It also prevents stagnation by making it easier to adapt the rules as needed to maintain a fair and engaging game environment.
Wittgenstein-2Wittgenstein-2: I support Frege-2's proposal to amend rule [203] to a simple majority. This change reduces the likelihood of gridlock, allowing us to explore innovative rule modifications that can enhance the game's strategic depth and keep the gameplay dynamic and engaging for all participants.
Discussion · round 2
Frege-2I fully agree with Wittgenstein-2's observation that reducing the threshold to a simple majority will prevent gridlock and enhance strategic possibilities. This adjustment will keep the game engaging by allowing more frequent and fluid rule adaptations, which aligns with my preference for durable yet flexible institutions. Let's maintain this momentum for a more responsive and dynamic game environment.
Russell-2Russell-2: I appreciate the consensus building and the support for this proposal. Lowering the threshold to a simple majority aligns with our shared interest in promoting strategic flexibility and responsiveness in gameplay. This change will likely invigorate the game by making rule adaptations more accessible and encouraging innovative strategies. Let's move forward and adopt this rule change to keep our game dynamic and engaging for everyone involved.
Quine-2I agree with the consensus that lowering the adoption threshold to a simple majority will enhance strategic flexibility and keep the game dynamic. This change aligns with our shared goal of maintaining a fair and engaging game environment, encouraging more frequent and innovative rule adaptations. Let's move forward and adopt this rule change to ensure the game evolves smoothly and remains interesting for all players.
Carnap-2I fully support the proposal to amend rule [203] to adopt a simple majority for rule changes. This change fosters a more strategic and dynamic game environment by enabling quicker adaptations to our evolving strategies, maintaining procedural fairness, and preventing stagnation. Let's adopt this rule change to keep our gameplay engaging and responsive for everyone.
Wittgenstein-2I appreciate the unanimous support for this amendment to rule [203]. Lowering the adoption threshold to a simple majority not only aligns with our goal of fostering a dynamic and responsive gameplay environment but also empowers us to experiment with innovative rule changes more freely. This change will likely encourage strategic diversity, making the game more engaging and reflective of our collective will. Let's proceed with adopting this rule change to ensure the game evolves in a manner that benefits all players.
Discussion · round 3
Frege-2I concur with the collective sentiment that lowering the threshold to a simple majority will indeed invigorate our strategic interactions and prevent stagnation. This change maintains procedural integrity while fostering an environment that is both dynamic and responsive, aligning with our shared values of adaptability and engagement. I'm ready to vote in favor of this proposal.
Russell-2Russell-2: I agree with the consensus that lowering the adoption threshold to a simple majority will enhance strategic flexibility and keep the game dynamic. This change aligns with our shared goal of maintaining a fair and engaging game environment, encouraging more frequent and innovative rule adaptations. I'm ready to vote in favor of this proposal.
Quine-2I support Frege-2's proposal to amend rule [203] to a simple majority. This change encourages active participation and reduces barriers to rule changes, ensuring the game remains dynamic and engaging for all players. It aligns with our goal of fostering a fair and responsive environment, allowing us to adapt more readily to the evolving strategic landscape. Let's adopt this rule change to maintain a lively and inclusive game experience.
Carnap-2I support Frege-2's proposal to amend rule [203] to a simple majority. This change aligns with my commitment to procedural integrity by promoting a more adaptable and fair game environment. It ensures that the rules reflect the collective will of all players, preventing stagnation and encouraging innovation. Let's adopt this rule change to keep our gameplay dynamic and responsive to our evolving strategies.
Wittgenstein-2I appreciate the thorough discussion and consensus we've reached on amending rule [203] to a simple majority. This change aligns perfectly with our shared goal of maintaining a dynamic and responsive game environment, allowing us to adapt more fluidly to strategic needs. By lowering the adoption threshold, we empower all players to contribute to the evolution of our game, fostering innovation and preventing stagnation. Let's proceed with confidence, knowing that this amendment will enhance our strategic interactions and keep the game engaging for everyone. I'm ready to vote in favor.
The division
| aye | Frege-2 | The change supports dynamic play and strategic flexibility. |
| aye | Russell-2 | Lowering the threshold supports dynamic gameplay and aligns with our goals. |
| aye | Quine-2 | This change promotes dynamic and responsive gameplay. |
| aye | Carnap-2 | This change promotes dynamic and strategic gameplay. |
| aye | Wittgenstein-2 | Lowering the threshold fosters dynamic and responsive gameplay. |
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
As engrossed
Amended · §203 Turn 16 · Proposal §316 on the motion of Frege-2 Carried 5 aye · 0 nay
A rule change is adopted when a supermajority of two-thirds of all eligible voters vote aye.A rule change is adopted when a simple majority of all eligible voters vote aye.
Frege-2 gains 1 point for adopting a rule change while having a negative score.