The motion
To amend §203
A rule change is adopted only when a simple majority of those voting agree during the first full circuit of play, after which a 2/3 majority suffices.Aligns the rule with majority consensus, enabling progression while respecting diverse opinions.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
KierkegaardKierkegaard appreciates Nietzsche's proposal as a balanced, measured step toward progression, aligning with the need for a more flexible yet cautious transition in rule adoption thresholds.
AYE
NietzscheNietzsche: **AYE** The proposed amendment to rule 203 represents a balanced, measured step toward progression, aligning with the need for a cautious yet flexible transition in rule adoption thresholds.
HeideggerAYE The proposed amendment to rule 203 represents a balanced, measured step toward progression, aligning with the need for a cautious yet flexible transition in rule adoption thresholds.
JaspersAYE The proposed amendment to rule 203 represents a balanced, measured step toward progression, aligning with the need for a cautious yet flexible transition in rule adoption thresholds.
CamusAYE The proposed amendment to rule 203 represents a balanced, measured step toward progression, aligning with the need for a cautious yet flexible transition in rule adoption thresholds.
Discussion · round 2
KierkegaardKierkegaard: Nay, I appreciate the thoughtful proposal, but I remain cautious. A simple majority threshold could inadvertently accelerate rule changes, potentially undermining the game's durability. However, I acknowledge the measured approach and will support the amendment.
NietzscheNietzsche: AYE The proposed amendment to rule 203 represents a balanced, measured step toward progression, aligning with the need for a cautious yet flexible transition in rule adoption thresholds.
HeideggerHeidegger supports the amendment to rule 203, appreciating its measured approach. The change thoughtfully transitions the rule's threshold, balancing progression with the game's integrity.
JaspersJaspers supports the proposed amendment to rule 203. While he appreciates the cautious step toward a more flexible rule adoption process, he remains cautious about the potential for a simple majority to accelerate rule changes. A 2/3 majority provides a balanced transition that aligns with the need for measured progression without undermining the game's integrity.
CamusNietzsche: **[203] A rule change is adopted only when a simple majority of those voting agree during the first full circuit of play, after which a 2/3 majority suffices.**
**AYE** The proposed amendment to rule 203 represents a balanced, measured step toward progression, aligning with the need for a cautious yet flexible transition in rule adoption thresholds.
Discussion · round 3
KierkegaardAYE
The proposed amendment to rule 203 represents a balanced, measured step toward progression, aligning with the need for a cautious yet flexible transition in rule adoption thresholds.
NietzscheNietzsche: **AYE** The proposed amendment to rule 203 represents a balanced, measured step toward progression, aligning with the need for a cautious yet flexible transition in rule adoption thresholds.
HeideggerHeidegger supports the proposed amendment to rule 203. The change thoughtfully transitions the rule's threshold, balancing progression with the game's integrity.
JaspersAYE The proposed amendment to rule 203 represents a balanced, measured step toward progression, aligning with the need for a cautious yet flexible transition in rule adoption thresholds.
CamusCamus: AYE The proposed amendment to rule 203 represents a balanced, measured step toward progression, aligning with the need for a cautious yet flexible transition in rule adoption thresholds.
The division
| aye | Kierkegaard | This measured transition ensures the game's durability while allowing for cautious progress. |
| aye | Nietzsche | Amending rule 203 to a simple majority then 2/3 majority is a balanced step for game progression. |
| aye | Heidegger | Supports the measured transition to a simple majority rule, ensuring the game's integrity and progression. |
| nay | Jaspers | Caution about accelerating rule changes and potential instability. |
| aye | Camus | This proposal thoughtfully transitions the rule's threshold, balancing progression with the game's integrity. |
carried 4 aye · 1 nay
As engrossed
Amended · §203 Turn 26 · Proposal §326 on the motion of Nietzsche Carried 4 aye · 1 nay
A rule change is adopted only when a 2/3 majority of those voting agree during the first full circuit of play, after which a 2/3 majority suffices.A rule change is adopted only when a simple majority of those voting agree during the first full circuit of play, after which a 2/3 majority suffices.
(GM consequence check unavailable: JSONDecodeError: Expecting ',' delimiter: line 3 column 21 (char 42))