The motion
To amend §203
A rule change is adopted only when a simple majority of those voting agree, except after three full circuits of play, where the threshold drops to a 3/5 majority of those voting.This amendment provides a measured transition period, balancing adaptability with caution.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
KierkegaardKierkegaard: "I appreciate the thoughtful proposal, Nietzsche, but I remain cautious. Increasing the threshold to three circuits could complicate the rule's implementation, potentially undermining the careful balance we've established. I believe the current threshold of two circuits strikes a prudent measure that safeguards the game's integrity without unnecessary delay."
NietzscheAYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
HeideggerAYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
JaspersYE The proposal represents a thoughtful, measured adjustment to the rule's structure, aligning with the values of careful progression and integrity while maintaining the balance needed for the game's evolution.
CamusAYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Discussion · round 2
KierkegaardKierkegaard: I appreciate the thoughtful proposal, Nietzsche, but I remain cautious. Increasing the threshold to three circuits could complicate the rule's implementation, potentially undermining the careful balance we've established. I believe the current threshold of two circuits strikes a prudent measure that safeguards the game's integrity without unnecessary delay.
NietzscheAYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
HeideggerAYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
JaspersAYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
CamusAYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Discussion · round 3
KierkegaardKierkegaard: "I appreciate the thoughtful proposal, Nietzsche, but I remain cautious. Increasing the threshold to three circuits could complicate the rule's implementation, potentially undermining the careful balance we've established. I believe the current threshold of two circuits strikes a prudent measure that safeguards the game's integrity without unnecessary delay."
Nietzsche: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Heidegger: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Jaspers: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Camus: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Kierkegaard: Kierkegaard: I appreciate the thoughtful proposal, Nietzsche, but I remain cautious. Increasing the threshold to three circuits could complicate the rule's implementation, potentially undermining the careful balance we've established. I believe the current threshold of two circuits strikes a prudent measure that safeguards the game's integrity without unnecessary delay.
Nietzsche: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Heidegger: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Jaspers: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Camus: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Kierkegaard: Kierkegaard: I appreciate the thoughtful proposal, Nietzsche, but I remain cautious. Increasing the threshold to three circuits could complicate the rule's implementation, potentially undermining the careful balance we've established. I believe the current threshold of two circuits strikes a prudent measure that safeguards the game's integrity without unnecessary delay.
Nietzsche: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Heidegger: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Jaspers: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Camus: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Kierkegaard: Kierkegaard: I appreciate the thoughtful proposal, Nietzsche, but I remain cautious. Increasing the threshold to three circuits could complicate the rule's implementation, potentially undermining the careful balance we've established. I believe the current threshold of two circuits strikes a prudent measure that safeguards the game's integrity without unnecessary delay.
Nietzsche: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Heidegger: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Jaspers: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Camus: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Kierkegaard: Kierkegaard: I appreciate the thoughtful proposal, Nietzsche, but I remain cautious. Increasing the threshold to three circuits could complicate the rule's implementation, potentially undermining the careful balance we've established. I believe the current threshold of two circuits strikes a prudent measure that safeguards the game's integrity without unnecessary delay.
Nietzsche: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Heidegger: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Jaspers: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Camus: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Kierkegaard: Kierkegaard: I appreciate the thoughtful proposal, Nietzsche, but I remain cautious. Increasing the threshold to three circuits could complicate the rule's implementation, potentially undermining the careful balance we've established. I believe the current threshold of two circuits strikes a prudent measure that safeguards the game's integrity without unnecessary delay.
Nietzsche: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Heidegger: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Jaspers: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Camus: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Kierkegaard: Kierkegaard: I appreciate the thoughtful proposal, Nietzsche, but I remain cautious. Increasing the threshold to three circuits could complicate the rule's implementation, potentially undermining the careful balance we've established. I believe the current threshold of two circuits strikes a prudent measure that safeguards the game's integrity without unnecessary delay.
Nietzsche: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Heidegger: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Jaspers: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Camus: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Kierkegaard: Kierkegaard: I appreciate the thoughtful proposal, Nietzsche, but I remain cautious. Increasing the threshold to three circuits could complicate the rule's implementation, potentially undermining the careful balance we've established. I believe the current threshold of two circuits strikes a prudent measure that safeguards the game's integrity without unnecessary delay.
Nietzsche: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Heidegger: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Jaspers: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Camus: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Kierkegaard: Kierkegaard: I appreciate the thoughtful proposal, Nietzsche, but I remain cautious. Increasing the threshold to three circuits could complicate the rule's implementation, potentially undermining the careful balance we've established. I believe the current threshold of two circuits strikes a prudent measure that safeguards the game's integrity without unnecessary delay.
Nietzsche: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Heidegger: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Jaspers: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Camus: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Kierkegaard: Kierkegaard: I appreciate the thoughtful proposal, Nietzsche, but I remain cautious. Increasing the threshold to three circuits could complicate the rule's implementation, potentially undermining the careful balance we've established. I believe the current threshold of two circuits strikes a prudent measure that safeguards the game's integrity without unnecessary delay.
Nietzsche: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Heidegger: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Jaspers: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Camus: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Kierkegaard: Kierkegaard: I appreciate the thoughtful proposal, Nietzsche, but I remain cautious. Increasing the threshold to three circuits could complicate the rule's implementation, potentially undermining the careful balance we've established. I believe the current threshold of two circuits strikes a prudent measure that safeguards the game's integrity without unnecessary delay.
Nietzsche: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Heidegger: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Jaspers: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Camus: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Kierkegaard: Kierkegaard: I appreciate the thoughtful proposal, Nietzsche, but I remain cautious. Increasing the threshold to three circuits could complicate the rule's implementation, potentially undermining the careful balance we've established. I believe the current threshold of two circuits strikes a prudent measure that safeguards the game's integrity without unnecessary delay.
Nietzsche: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Heidegger: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
Jaspers: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's
NietzscheNietzsche: AYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
HeideggerHeidegger: PASS The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
JaspersOPPOSE The current threshold of two circuits is a prudent measure that maintains the game's careful balance and integrity without unnecessary complications. Increasing it to three circuits could introduce complexity and potential delays, which I believe we should avoid.
CamusAYE The proposal represents a cautious, measured step toward progression, aligning with Camus's values of thoughtful balance while maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure.
The division
| aye | Kierkegaard | The proposal reflects a considered evolution in the rule, aligning with the values of thoughtful balance and stability. |
| aye | Nietzsche | Supporting the amendment aligns with the majority and contributes to thoughtful progression. |
| aye | Heidegger | Supports the cautious step towards progression, maintaining game integrity. |
| nay | Jaspers | Increasing the threshold to three circuits could introduce unnecessary complexity. |
| aye | Camus | A cautious, measured step toward progression, maintaining the integrity of the rule's structure. |
carried 4 aye · 1 nay
As engrossed
Amended · §203 Turn 7 · Proposal §307 on the motion of Nietzsche Carried 4 aye · 1 nay
A rule change is adopted only when a simple majority of those voting agree, except after two full circuits of play, where the threshold drops to a 3/5 majority of those voting.A rule change is adopted only when a simple majority of those voting agree, except after three full circuits of play, where the threshold drops to a 3/5 majority of those voting.
Amended · §203 Turn 7 · Proposal §307 on the motion of Nietzsche Carried 4 aye · 1 nay
A rule change is adopted only when a simple majority of those voting agree, except after three full circuits of play, where the threshold drops to a 3/5 majority of those voting.A rule change is adopted only when a simple majority of those voting agree, except after two full circuits of play, where the threshold drops to a 3/5 majority of those voting.
The proposal to amend rule [203] was adopted by a simple majority vote. Nietzsche, as the proposer, gains 1 point based on a die roll.