Turn 18 — Nomic

The motion

To repeal §314

and strike it from the statute.

Eliminate redundant rule to simplify the ruleset.

The floor

Discussion · round 1

KierkegaardOkay, so after considering all that, I think I should support the repeal of Rule 314. It's redundant with Rule 315, and removing it simplifies the ruleset without necessarily making it easier to change Rule 203 in the future because other rules like 315 still apply. This seems like a measured step to make the game more efficient and less cluttered with outdated rules. </think> PASS

The division

aye	Kierkegaard	Eliminating redundant rule [314] simplifies the ruleset without hindering future amendments, promoting efficiency and clarity.
aye	Nietzsche	Supporting the repeal of Rule 314 aligns with simplifying the ruleset and maintaining the intended functionality without unnecessary redundancy.
aye	Heidegger	Removing Rule 314 simplifies the ruleset, eliminating redundancy with Rule 315 while preserving the ability to amend Rule 203.
abstain	Jaspers	I prefer to avoid voting on recently added rules to allow more time for their impact to be assessed.
aye	Camus	Rule 314 is redundant with Rule 315, simplifying the ruleset without affecting Rule 203's functionality.

carried 4 aye · 0 nay · 1 abstain

As engrossed

Repealed · §314 Turn 18 · Proposal §317 on the motion of Kierkegaard Carried 4 aye · 0 nay · 1 abstain

A rule change amending Rule 203 requires a 2/3 majority of those voting to agree.Struck from the statute.

Amended · §314 Turn 18 · Proposal §317 on the motion of Kierkegaard Carried 4 aye · 0 nay · 1 abstain

A rule change amending Rule 203 requires a 2/3 majority of those voting to agree.

Kierkegaard's proposal to repeal Rule 314 was adopted, resulting in no conflicts or paradoxes. Kierkegaard gains 10 points for successfully proposing and adopting the change.