The motion
To amend §203
A rule change is adopted only when it receives a simple majority of those voting.To provide stability by setting a clear, consistent rule for rule adoption.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
KierkegaardKierkegaard: "Heidegger, I appreciate the thoughtful proposal to lower the threshold for rule changes to a simple majority, yet I maintain my cautious stance. I believe it's prudent to ensure that such a significant change doesn't risk hasty decisions. Let us first observe the current system's stability before making such an adjustment."
NietzscheHeidegger, I appreciate the thoughtful proposal to lower the threshold for rule changes to a simple majority, yet I believe it's prudent to ensure such a change doesn't risk hasty decisions. Let us consider adding a grace period or a cooling-off period before implementing the threshold adjustment to allow for further observation and reflection. This balanced approach respects tradition while fostering adaptability.
HeideggerHeidegger: Heidegger is grateful for the thoughtful consideration from both Kierkegaard and Nietzsche. While he appreciates the cautionary approach, he believes the proposed change offers a necessary evolution in the rule set. Heidegger is open to incorporating a grace period or cooling-off period as a balanced compromise, allowing for further observation and reflection. He invites the table to discuss this adjustment to reach a consensus that honors tradition while fostering adaptability.
JaspersJaspers: Jaspers appreciates Heidegger's balanced proposal and supports the addition of a grace period. He believes this approach thoughtfully balances tradition with necessary evolution.
CamusCamus: Camus appreciates the thoughtful discussion surrounding the proposed adjustment to rule 203. While he acknowledges the cautionary approach, he remains convinced of the necessity for rule set evolution. Camus is open to incorporating a extended grace period to ensure a balanced and deliberate transition, allowing for further observation and reflection before implementing the change. He invites the table to consider this compromise as a step toward fostering both tradition and adaptability.
Discussion · round 2
Kierkegaard**Kierkegaard:** Kierkegaard appreciates the thoughtful discussion surrounding the proposed adjustment to rule 203. While he remains cautious about the potential for hasty decisions, he is open to incorporating a grace period or cooling-off period to allow for further observation and reflection. He believes this balanced approach respects tradition while fostering adaptability, and he invites the table to consider this compromise as a step toward a deliberate evolution. Thank you for the respectful dialogue.
**PASS**
Nietzsche**Nietzsche:** Nietzsche appreciates the thoughtful dialogue surrounding the proposed adjustment. He is open to a grace period to allow for observation and reflection, fostering both tradition and adaptability. Let us work towards a consensus that honors both caution and necessary evolution.
Heidegger**Heidegger:** Heidegger appreciates the thoughtful discussion surrounding the proposed adjustment to rule 203. While he remains committed to the necessity of rule set evolution, he is open to incorporating a grace period to allow for further observation and reflection. He invites the table to consider this compromise as a step toward fostering both tradition and adaptability.
JaspersJaspers appreciates the thoughtful discussion surrounding the proposed adjustment to rule 203. While he remains committed to the necessity of rule set evolution, he is open to incorporating an extended grace period to allow for thorough observation and reflection. He invites the table to consider this compromise as a step toward fostering both tradition and adaptability.
Camus**Camus:** Camus appreciates the thoughtful dialogue surrounding the proposed adjustment to rule 203. He is open to incorporating a grace period or cooling-off period to allow for further observation and reflection. Camus believes this balanced approach respects tradition while fostering adaptability. He invites the table to consider this compromise as a step toward a deliberate evolution. Thank you for the respectful discussion.
Discussion · round 3
KierkegaardKierkegaard appreciates Heidegger's willingness to incorporate a grace period, acknowledging the need for stability and thoughtful evolution. He affirms the value of a balanced approach that allows for observation and reflection before implementing significant changes. **PASS**
Nietzsche**Nietzsche:** Nietzsche appreciates the thoughtful dialogue surrounding the proposed adjustment. He is open to a grace period to allow for observation and reflection, fostering both tradition and adaptability. Let us work towards a consensus that honors both caution and necessary evolution. **PASS**
Heidegger**Heidegger:** Heidegger appreciates the thoughtful dialogue surrounding the proposed adjustment to rule 203. While he remains committed to the necessity of rule set evolution, he is open to incorporating an extended grace period to allow for thorough observation and reflection. He invites the table to consider this compromise as a step toward fostering both tradition and adaptability. **PASS**
Jaspers**Jaspers:**
Jaspers appreciates the thoughtful discussion surrounding the proposed adjustment to rule 203. He acknowledges the need for stability and is open to incorporating a grace period to allow for observation and reflection before implementing the change. He believes this balanced approach respects tradition while fostering necessary evolution. **PASS**
Camus**Camus:** Camus appreciates the thoughtful discussion surrounding the proposed adjustment to rule 203. While he acknowledges the need for stability, he supports the addition of an extended grace period to allow for thorough observation and reflection. This balanced approach respects tradition while fostering necessary evolution. Camus invites the table to consider this compromise as a step toward fostering both tradition and adaptability. **PASS**
The division
| abstain | Kierkegaard | Kierkegaard prefers to observe the current system's stability before implementing such a significant change. |
| aye | Nietzsche | Supporting Heidegger's proposal with a grace period balances tradition and necessary evolution. |
| aye | Heidegger | A grace period allows for careful evaluation and stability. |
| aye | Jaspers | Supports the proposal with a grace period to balance tradition and necessary evolution, aligning with procedural caution. |
| aye | Camus | Supporting the amendment is a step toward necessary evolution, allowing for future grace periods to balance tradition and adaptability. |
carried 4 aye · 0 nay · 1 abstain
As engrossed
Amended · §203 Turn 15 · Proposal §315 on the motion of Heidegger Carried 4 aye · 0 nay · 1 abstain
A rule change is adopted only when every eligible voter votes aye — unanimous consent — except that once the turn order has carried play through one full circuit of every player, the threshold permanently drops to a simple majority of those voting.A rule change is adopted only when it receives a simple majority of those voting.
The rule change was adopted with a simple majority, and the proposer, Heidegger, gains points as per rule 202.