The motion
To add a new rule
For every player whose score is less than 10, grant 5 bonus points at the start of each turn.Encourages balanced gameplay and prevents runaway leaders.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
FoucaultAye. Deleuze's proposal introduces a balanced mechanism to support struggling players while maintaining game stability. It encourages active participation and can enhance the game's longevity by preventing any single player from falling too far behind.
Derrida**Derrida's Contribution:** I support Deleuze's proposal as a strategic balance that encourages competition and prevents any single player from dominating early on. It adds a layer of fairness, allowing players like myself to catch up and participate more actively.
DeleuzeAye. Deleuze's proposal introduces a balanced mechanism to support struggling players while maintaining game stability. It encourages active participation and can enhance the game's longevity by preventing any single player from falling too far behind.
MerleauPontyAye. Deleuze's proposal introduces a balanced mechanism to support struggling players while maintaining game stability. It encourages active participation and can enhance the game's longevity by preventing any single player from falling too far behind.
RicoeurAye. Deleuze's proposal introduces a balanced mechanism to support struggling players while maintaining game stability. It encourages active participation and can enhance the game's longevity by preventing any single player from falling too far behind.
Discussion · round 2
Foucault**Foucault's Contribution:** Aye. Deleuze's proposal introduces a balanced mechanism to support struggling players while maintaining game stability. It encourages active participation and can enhance the game's longevity by preventing any single player from falling too far behind.
Derrida**Derrida's Contribution:** I support Deleuze's proposal as a strategic balance that encourages competition and prevents any single player from dominating early on. It adds a layer of fairness, allowing players like myself to catch up and participate more actively.
Deleuze**Deleuze's Contribution:** Aye. Deleuze's proposal introduces a balanced mechanism to support struggling players while maintaining game stability. It encourages active participation and can enhance the game's longevity by preventing any single player from falling too far behind.
MerleauPonty**Deleuze's Proposal:**
Add a new rule: "For every player whose score is less than 10, grant 5 bonus points at the start of each turn."
**MerleauPonty's Contribution:**
Aye. Deleuze's proposal introduces a balanced mechanism to support struggling players while maintaining game stability. It encourages active participation and can enhance the game's longevity by preventing any single player from falling too far behind.
RicoeurAye. Deleuze's proposal introduces a balanced mechanism to support struggling players while maintaining game stability. It encourages active participation and can enhance the game's longevity by preventing any single player from falling too far behind.
Discussion · round 3
Foucault**Foucault's Contribution:**
Aye. Deleuze's proposal introduces a balanced mechanism to support struggling players while maintaining game stability. It encourages active participation and can enhance the game's longevity by preventing any single player from falling too far behind. I agree that this addition will promote fairness and keep the game dynamic.
Derrida**Derrida's Contribution:**
I support Deleuze's proposal as it introduces a balanced mechanism to support struggling players while maintaining game stability. It encourages active participation and can enhance the game's longevity by preventing any single player from falling too far behind. This addition will promote fairness and keep the game dynamic.
Deleuze**Deleuze's Contribution:**
Aye. My proposal introduces a balanced mechanism to support struggling players while maintaining game stability. It encourages active participation and can enhance the game's longevity by preventing any single player from falling too far behind. I appreciate the support and believe this addition will promote fairness and keep the game dynamic.
MerleauPonty**MerleauPonty's Contribution:**
Nay. While Deleuze's proposal aims to support struggling players, it would violate rule 311 by increasing the number of mutable rules beyond the allowed limit of 15. Adding this new rule would exceed that limit, making it impermissible under the current ruleset.
Ricoeur**Ricoeur's Contribution:**
Nay. I agree with Merleau-Ponty's concern. Adding this new mutable rule would exceed the limit set by rule 311, which caps mutable rules at 15. To support struggling players, we should propose an amendment that complies with this limit, perhaps by adjusting an existing rule or through transmutation.
The division
| nay | Foucault | Adding this rule would exceed the 15 mutable rule limit set by rule 311. |
| nay | Derrida | Adding this rule would exceed the 15 mutable rule limit set by rule 311. |
| nay | Deleuze | Adding the rule would exceed the 15 mutable rules limit set by rule 311. |
| nay | MerleauPonty | Adding this rule would exceed the 15 mutable rules limit set by rule 311. |
| nay | Ricoeur | Adding this rule would exceed the 15 mutable rule limit set by rule 311. |
rejected 0 aye · 5 nay
Rule 206 applies: proposer loses 10, nay voters gain 10 each. Foucault reaches 22 and wins.