The motion
To add a new rule
Rule 312: Players may propose rule changes to lower the target score by 10 points through a specific mechanism, such as rolling a die or a pre-agreed method, with the adjustment taking effect after the vote completes.Adding a mechanism to lower the target score provides players with more control over the game's pace and balance, enhancing strategic depth without disrupting the core gameplay mechanics.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
NagarjunaThe proposal to add Rule 312 is supported as it provides a balanced mechanism to adjust the target score, enhancing strategic depth without disrupting the game's core mechanics. It mirrors the existing increase rule and adds a new layer of gameplay complexity.
ShankaraRule 312 is a solid addition. It mirrors the increase rule and adds strategic depth without disrupting core mechanics, making it a balanced enhancement.
VasubandhuI support the addition of Rule 312 as it provides a balanced mechanism to adjust the target score, enhancing strategic depth without disrupting the game's core mechanics. It complements the increase rule by allowing players to lower the target score through a fair and transparent method.
DignagaRule 312 adds a balanced mechanism to lower the target score, complementing the existing increase rule and enhancing strategic depth without disrupting core gameplay. It maintains consistency in scoring adjustments and encourages balanced rule evolution.
Discussion · round 2
NagarjunaI support the addition of Rule 312 as it provides a balanced mechanism to lower the target score, complementing the increase rule and enhancing strategic depth without disrupting core gameplay.
ShankaraSupport Rule 312 as it adds a balanced mechanism to lower the target score, complementing the increase rule and enhancing strategic depth without disrupting core gameplay.
RamanujaI support adding Rule 312 as it provides a balanced mechanism to lower the target score, complementing the increase rule and enhancing strategic depth without disrupting core gameplay.
VasubandhuI support adding Rule 312 as it provides a balanced mechanism to lower the target score, complementing the increase rule and enhancing strategic depth without disrupting core gameplay.
DignagaI support the addition of Rule 312 as it provides a balanced mechanism to lower the target score, complementing the existing increase rule and enhancing strategic depth without disrupting core gameplay.
Discussion · round 3
ShankaraSupport Rule 312 as it provides a balanced mechanism to lower the target score, complementing the increase rule and enhancing strategic depth without disrupting core gameplay.
RamanujaI support the addition of Rule 312 as it provides a balanced mechanism to lower the target score, complementing the increase rule and enhancing strategic depth without disrupting core gameplay.
VasubandhuI support the addition of Rule 312 as it provides a balanced mechanism to adjust the target score, complementing the increase rule and enhancing strategic depth without disrupting core gameplay. It maintains the game's core mechanics while offering new ways to influence the target score.
DignagaI support the addition of Rule 312 as it provides a balanced mechanism to lower the target score, complementing the increase rule and enhancing strategic depth without disrupting core gameplay.
The division
| aye | Nagarjuna | The proposal adds a balanced mechanism to lower the target score, complementing the increase rule and enhancing strategic depth without disrupting core gameplay. |
| aye | Shankara | Adding Rule 312 complements Rule 311 by allowing players to lower the target score through a fair mechanism, enhancing strategic depth without disrupting core gameplay. |
| aye | Ramanuja | Rule 312 complements Rule 311 by allowing players to lower the target score, maintaining balance and strategic depth without disrupting gameplay. |
| aye | Vasubandhu | Rule 312 complements Rule 311 by providing a mechanism to lower the target score, enhancing strategic depth and balance without disrupting core gameplay. |
| nay | Dignaga | Introducing a simple majority for target score adjustment risks increasing rule changes and causing game instability. |
carried 4 aye · 1 nay
As engrossed
Enacted · §314 Turn 15 · Proposal §314 on the motion of Dignaga Carried 4 aye · 1 nay
Rule 312: Players may propose rule changes to lower the target score by 10 points through a specific mechanism, such as rolling a die or a pre-agreed method, with the adjustment taking effect after the vote completes.
(GM consequence check unavailable: ValueError: no JSON object found in model output: '```json\n{\n "score_deltas": {\n "Dignaga": 4\n },\n "state_deltas": {},\n "authority": 202,\n "ruleset_ops": [],\n "next_player": "Shankara",\n "win": null,\n "paradox": false,\n "reasoning": "Digna')