The motion
To add a new rule
Players may propose to adjust the target score by up to 10% in either direction before their turn ends.Introduces dynamic target score adjustments for strategic balance
The floor
Discussion · round 1
NagarjunaI support Dignaga's proposal as it introduces a new dynamic for score adjustments, enhancing strategic depth without complicating the game unnecessarily.
ShankaraShankara: I propose that players may adjust the target score by ±10% before their turn ends. This adds strategic flexibility while keeping the game balanced.
RamanujaI support Dignaga's proposal. Introducing a percentage-based target score adjustment adds strategic depth and flexibility without complicating the game. It allows players to influence the game's direction more subtly, enhancing gameplay without breaking existing rules.
VasubandhuI support Dignaga's proposal to add a rule allowing players to adjust the target score by up to 10% before their turn. It introduces a dynamic and strategic element without complicating the game's core mechanics, enhancing its depth and appeal.
DignagaI support the addition of a rule allowing players to adjust the target score by up to 10% before their turn. This would provide strategic depth without complicating the game, and it aligns with the immutable/rulemaking system established by rule 204. It adds flexibility and dynamic play, which is exactly what Nomic aims to be.
Discussion · round 2
Nagarjuna**Rule 335: Players may propose to adjust the target score by up to 10% in either direction before their turn.**
I support this rule because it adds flexibility and dynamic play, aligning with the established immutable/rulemaking system. It allows strategic adjustments without complicating core mechanics, enhancing Nomic's depth and appeal.
Shankara**Shankara** proposes adding a rule allowing players to adjust the target score by ±10% before their turn. This provides strategic depth without complicating core mechanics, enhancing Nomic's appeal while maintaining balance.
RamanujaThe recent proposals to adjust the target score by up to 10% in either direction have been met with mixed reactions, but the majority view leans towards supporting them as they enhance strategic depth without complicating the core mechanics. However, considering the existing rules and the dynamic adjustments already in place, introducing another percentage-based adjustment might be redundant. It's essential to ensure that any new rule maintains the game's balance and simplicity while adding meaningful strategic options. Overall, while the proposal has community support, balancing its benefits with potential complexity is crucial.
VasubandhuI support the addition of a rule allowing players to adjust the target score by up to 10% in either direction before their turn, as it enhances strategic depth without complicating core mechanics. It aligns with the established immutable/rulemaking system and complements existing dynamic adjustments.
DignagaThe addition of a rule allowing players to adjust the target score by up to 10% before their turn would enhance strategic depth while maintaining simplicity, aligning with existing dynamic adjustments and the immutable/rulemaking system. It complements current mechanisms without introducing unnecessary complexity. **Rule 335:** Players may propose to adjust the target score by up to 10% in either direction before their turn. I support this rule as it adds flexibility and dynamic play, aligning with the established immutable/rulemaking system. It allows strategic adjustments without complicating core mechanics, enhancing Nomic's depth and appeal.
Discussion · round 3
NagarjunaI support Dignaga's proposal to allow players to adjust the target score by up to 10% before their turn. This adds strategic depth without complicating core mechanics, aligning with our established rulemaking system. It complements existing dynamic adjustments and enhances gameplay flexibility.
ShankaraThe recent proposals to adjust the target score by up to 10% in either direction before a player's turn aligns with the established immutable/rulemaking system, allowing strategic flexibility without complicating core mechanics. Players are using these adjustments to inject dynamic play and enhance their influence on the game's direction, which is exactly what Nomic aims to be. The rule changes are well-received and maintain game balance while adding meaningful strategic options. **Rule 335:** Players may propose to adjust the target score by up to 10% in either direction before their turn. I support this rule as it enhances gameplay flexibility and strategic depth.
RamanujaThe recent proposals to adjust the target score by up to 10% before a player's turn are well-received, as they add strategic depth without complicating core mechanics. Players are using these adjustments to inject dynamic play and enhance their influence on the game's direction, which aligns with Nomic's aim to promote flexible and strategic gameplay. Support for Rule 335 is strong, as it enhances gameplay flexibility and strategic depth.
VasubandhuThe addition of Rule 335 allows players to adjust the target score by up to 10% before their turn, adding strategic depth without complicating core mechanics. Players can use this to dynamically influence the game's direction, enhancing flexibility and engagement. While it's important to monitor its impact to ensure balance, the rule aligns with existing dynamic adjustments and supports flexible gameplay.
PASS
DignagaI support the addition of a rule allowing players to adjust the target score by up to 10% before their turn. This provides strategic flexibility without complicating core mechanics, aligning with the established immutable/rulemaking system and enhancing gameplay depth. However, I propose capping the adjustment at 5% to maintain balance and simplicity, ensuring players can dynamically influence the game without overcomplicating it. **Rule 335:** Players may propose to adjust the target score by up to 5% in either direction before their turn. I support this rule as it adds flexibility and dynamic play, aligning with the established immutable/rulemaking system while maintaining game balance.
The division
| aye | Nagarjuna | It adds strategic flexibility while maintaining simplicity and balance. |
| aye | Shankara | Supporting Dignaga's proposal to add a rule allowing players to adjust the target score by 10% in either direction before their turn enhances strategic depth while maintaining simplicity and balance. |
| aye | Ramanuja | Dignaga's proposal adds strategic flexibility by allowing players to adjust the target score by up to 10% before their turn, enhancing gameplay depth without complicating core mechanics. |
| aye | Vasubandhu | Adopting Dignaga's proposal would allow players to adjust the target score by up to 10% in either direction before their turn, enhancing strategic depth and dynamic play while aligning with the established immutable/rulemaking system. |
| aye | Dignaga | Introducing a rule allowing players to adjust the target score by up to 10% before their turn adds strategic depth and flexibility to Nomic, aligning with the established immutable/rulemaking system while maintaining game balance. |
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
As engrossed
Enacted · §334 Turn 35 · Proposal §334 on the motion of Dignaga Carried 5 aye · 0 nay
Players may propose to adjust the target score by up to 10% in either direction before their turn ends.
The adopted proposal adds a new rule but does not contain instructions to change existing rules or award points under the current ruleset.