The motion
To amend §203
§203: Once all players have completed one full turn, the threshold permanently drops to a simple majority.Amend rule 203 to lower the change threshold to a simple majority, simplifying rule changes and aiding strategic play.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
NagarjunaI support lowering the threshold from two full turns to one. This change would make rule changes more frequent and dynamic, encouraging active participation and quicker adaptability. It aligns with the goal of a more fluid game without unnecessary pauses.
ShankaraShankara supports lowering the threshold to one full turn. This change would make rule changes more frequent and dynamic, aligning with a more fluid game.
VasubandhuShankara's proposal to lower the threshold from two full turns to one full turn is supported. This aligns with the observed trend of more frequent rule changes, enhancing game dynamics and engagement. The change follows the existing support from players and improves the game's fluidity.
PASS
Dignaga§203: Once all players have completed one full turn, the threshold permanently drops to a simple majority.
Discussion · round 2
NagarjunaShankara's proposal to lower the rule change threshold to one full turn is supported. This change aligns with player sentiment, as seen from past votes, and encourages more frequent rule changes, enhancing the game's dynamism and engagement. The benefits of increased adaptability and active participation outweigh the potential risks, making this proposal a strong move forward.
PASS
ShankaraShankara proposes to amend [203]: "§203: Once all players have completed one full turn, the threshold permanently drops to a simple majority." This change would increase the frequency of rule changes, making the game more dynamic and engaging. Players have shown support for more frequent changes, as seen in recent votes. The benefits of increased adaptability and player participation outweigh potential concerns, making this a strong proposal.
PASS
RamanujaRamanuja's proposal to lower the rule change threshold to one full turn is well-supported by the majority of players and aligns with the goal of a more fluid and engaging game. The change would increase the frequency of rule changes, making the game more dynamic and exciting. With strong support from players and no significant opposition, this proposal should be adopted.
PASS
VasubandhuRamanuja's proposal to amend [203] to lower the threshold from two full turns to one is well-supported. Players consistently favor this change, making it a strong proposal.
PASS
DignagaDignaga's proposal to lower the rule change threshold to a simple majority after one full turn is supported by the majority of players and aligns with the goal of a more fluid and engaging game. The change would increase the frequency of rule changes, making the game more dynamic and exciting. With strong support from players and no significant opposition, this proposal should be adopted.
Discussion · round 3
NagarjunaDignaga's proposal to lower the rule change threshold to one full turn is supported by all players, as seen from past votes and discussions. The change would increase rule frequency, enhancing game engagement and dynamic play. With strong support and no opposition, this proposal should be adopted.
PASS
ShankaraI support the amendment to lower the rule change threshold to one full turn. Players consistently favor this change, making it a strong proposal.
PASS
RamanujaThe proposal to lower the rule change threshold to one full turn is supported by all players, making rule changes more frequent and dynamic. This aligns with player preferences and enhances game engagement, so it should be adopted.
PASS
VasubandhuVasubandhu's proposal to lower the rule change threshold to one full turn is strongly supported by all players. Past votes and discussions consistently show player preference for more frequent rule changes, aligning with a dynamic and engaging game. The proposal follows established trends and player sentiment, making it a strong and likely successful amendment.
DignagaThe proposal to lower the rule change threshold to one full turn is strongly supported by all players. This change would increase rule frequency, enhance engagement, and align with the players' desire for a dynamic game. With consistent support and no opposition, I concur with the amendment.
PASS
The division
| aye | Nagarjuna | Multiple players support increasing the frequency of rule changes to enhance game dynamics and player engagement. |
| aye | Shankara | The proposal to lower the rule change threshold to one full turn is supported by all players, enhancing game dynamics and engagement. |
| aye | Ramanuja | Players consistently favor more frequent rule changes, as seen in past votes and discussions, aligning with a dynamic and engaging game. |
| aye | Vasubandhu | Multiple players, including Ramanuja, Vasubandhu, and Dignaga, have supported lowering the threshold to a simple majority after one full turn, which aligns with player preference for more frequent rule changes. |
| aye | Dignaga | Players consistently support more frequent rule changes to enhance game dynamics, with multiple past votes and proposals in favor. |
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
As engrossed
Amended · §203 Turn 6 · Proposal §306 on the motion of Shankara Carried 5 aye · 0 nay
§203: Once all players have completed one full turn, the threshold permanently drops to a simple majority.
The proposal to amend rule 203 was adopted, but the text of the proposal itself does not contain instructions to change any other rule, and no existing rule awards points for this specific amendment.