The motion
To add a new rule
If a player's score is negative, that player may propose a rule change with the explicit intent of gaining points only, without proposing any other substantive rule change. Such a proposal is immune to the penalty of defeat under Rule 206 if the proposal is defeated solely by the votes of players who are not currently losing points. If a player's score is negative, that player may propose a rule change with the explicit intent of gaining points only, without proposing any other substantive rule change. Such a proposal is immune to the penalty of defeat under Rule 206 regardless of the voting outcome.Ruled out of order
The proposal attempts to enact a new rule but duplicates the text of an existing rule (Rule 318) and adds contradictory conditions, failing the requirement that a proposal be written in the exact words that will be voted on as a single coherent change.