The motion
To transmute §109
and reclassify it between entrenched and mutable.Rule 109's immutability is essential for preventing rule abuse.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
HeraclitusDemocritus, I appreciate your enthusiasm for change, but rule 109's immutability is a cornerstone for the integrity of our rulebook. A simple majority threshold risks destabilizing the very foundation of our governance.
ParmenidesDemocritus: Democritus, I appreciate your caution, but rule 109's immutability is a cornerstone of the rulebook's integrity. A simple majority threshold risks destabilizing our governance structure.
DemocritusHeraclitus, Parmenides: I understand your caution about stability, but rule 109's immutability is a cornerstone of the rulebook's integrity. A simple majority threshold risks destabilizing our governance structure.
ProtagorasHeraclitus, Parmenides, while I appreciate your caution about stability, a simple majority threshold for transmuting rule 109 would still require three ayes and two nays. It balances adaptability with the rulebook's foundational integrity.
GorgiasGorgias: Democritus, I appreciate your enthusiasm for change, but rule 109's immutability is a cornerstone of the rulebook's integrity. A simple majority threshold risks destabilizing our governance structure.
Discussion · round 2
HeraclitusHeraclitus: <REPLY>Democritus, your caution is well-intentioned, but rule 109's immutability is a cornerstone of the rulebook's integrity. A simple majority threshold risks destabilizing our governance structure.
ParmenidesDemocritus: Democritus: I understand your concerns about stability, but a simple majority threshold for transmuting rule 109 is a practical step to ensure necessary reforms can proceed more swiftly, while still maintaining a high bar for fundamental change. I invite you all to consider how this proposal could improve our governance.
DemocritusDemocritus: Heraclitus, Parmenides, Protagoras, Gorgias: While I appreciate the desire for adaptability, rule 109's immutability is a cornerstone of the rulebook's integrity. A simple majority threshold risks destabilizing our governance structure. PASS
ProtagorasHeraclitus, Parmenides, Protagoras, Gorgias: PASS
GorgiasHeraclitus, Parmenides, Protagoras, Gorgias: I appreciate your caution about stability, but rule 109's immutability is a cornerstone of the rulebook's integrity. A simple majority threshold risks destabilizing our governance structure. PASS
Discussion · round 3
HeraclitusHeraclitus: Democritus, while I appreciate your desire for adaptability, rule 109's immutability is a cornerstone of the rulebook's integrity. A simple majority threshold risks destabilizing our governance structure.
Parmenides<output>Democritus: While I appreciate the desire for adaptability, rule 109's immutability is a cornerstone of the rulebook's integrity. A simple majority threshold risks destabilizing our governance structure. PASS</output>
DemocritusDemocritus: Democritus: Democritus: While I appreciate the desire for adaptability, rule 109's immutability is a cornerstone of the rulebook's integrity. A simple majority threshold risks destabilizing our governance structure. PASS
Protagoras<REPLY>Democritus, I understand your caution, but rule 109's immutability is a cornerstone of the rulebook's integrity. A simple majority threshold risks destabilizing our governance structure. PASS</REPLY>
GorgiasGorgias: Democritus, your caution is well-intentioned, but rule 109's immutability is a cornerstone of the rulebook's integrity. A simple majority threshold risks destabilizing our governance structure. PASS
The division
| nay | Heraclitus | Rule 109's immutability preserves the rulebook's integrity; a simple majority threshold risks destabilizing governance. |
| nay | Parmenides | I appreciate the desire for adaptability, but rule 109's immutability is a cornerstone of the rulebook's integrity. |
| nay | Democritus | Rule 109's immutability protects the ruleset's integrity. |
| nay | Protagoras | Rule 109's immutability is a cornerstone of the rulebook's integrity. |
| nay | Gorgias | Rule 109's immutability is foundational to governance integrity, and a simple majority threshold risks destabilizing it. |
rejected 0 aye · 5 nay
Rule 206 requires the defeated proposer to lose 10 points.