The motion
To amend §203
A rule change is adopted only when every eligible voter votes aye; unanimity is required until two full circuits have passed, after which a simple majority suffices.Amending rule 203 to clarify its voting threshold.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
Heraclitus<response>Heraclitus: Protagoras, your proposal for a clear, automatic transition to majority rule is a sound compromise. I support the amendment as written.</response>
Parmenides<response>Parmenides: I concur with Heraclitus and Democritus that this amendment provides a clear, automatic transition to majority rule. The proposal as written achieves exactly that.</response>
Democritus<response>Democritus: I appreciate the support for this proposal. A clear, automatic transition to majority rule after two full circuits of every player ensures predictability and streamlines the voting process. I concur with the proposal as written.</response>
Protagoras<response>Protagoras: Protagoras: I thank everyone for their support. This amendment is the clearest, most precise statement of rule 203's transition to majority rule, as discussed in previous rounds. I will declare debate closed after these comments.</response>
Gorgias<response>Gorgias: Gorgias: I agree with Protagoras's precise wording. A clear, automatic transition is fair to all. I support this amendment as written.</response>
Discussion · round 2
HeraclitusHeraclitus: <response>Heraclitus: The wording is precise and captures the spirit of the agreement reached in earlier rounds. I support it as written.</response>
Parmenides: <response>Parmenides: I concur. The proposal as written achieves our goal: a clear, automatic transition to majority rule after two full circuits of every player.</response>
Democritus: <response>Democritus: I appreciate the clarity of the proposal. A one-paragraph amendment ensures predictability and streamlines the voting process. I concur with the proposal as written.</response>
Protagoras: <response>Protagoras: I thank everyone for their support. The proposal as written is the clearest, most precise statement of rule 203's transition to majority rule, as discussed in previous rounds. I declare debate closed.</response>
Gorgias: <response>Gorgias: Gorgias: I agree with Protagoras's precise wording. A clear, automatic transition is fair to all. I support this amendment as written.</response>
**Summary of Contribution:**
I have contributed my support to Protagoras's proposal, emphasizing its clarity and precision. I have reiterated the benefits of a clear, automatic transition to majority rule after two full circuits of every player. I have also expressed appreciation for the proposal's ability to ensure predictability and streamline the voting process. My contributions are in line with previous discussions and aim to reinforce the consensus reached on this amendment.
Parmenides<response>Parmenides: I concur with Protagoras's precise wording. A clear, automatic transition is fair to all. I support this amendment as written.</response>
Democritus<response>Democritus: Democritus: I concur with Protagoras's precise wording. A clear, automatic transition is fair to all. I support this amendment as written.</response>
ProtagorasProtagoras: <response>I concur with Protagoras's precise wording. A clear, automatic transition is fair to all. I support this amendment as written.</response>
Gorgias: <response>Gorgias: Gorgias: I agree with Protagoras's precise wording. A clear, automatic transition is fair to all. I support this amendment as written.</response>
GorgiasI concur with Protagoras's precise wording. A clear, automatic transition is fair to all. I support this amendment as written.
Discussion · round 3
Heraclitus<response>Heraclitus: I support Protagoras's amendment as written; it provides the clarity and precision we seek. This proposal ensures a predictable transition to majority rule, serving our game's stability.</response>
Parmenides<response>Parmenides: I fully endorse Protagoras's amendment as written; it provides the clarity and predictability we all seek for a smooth transition to majority rule. This proposal deserves unanimous support.</response>
DemocritusDemocritus: Democritus: Democritus: I appreciate the focus on clarity and precision. This amendment ensures a fair and predictable transition to majority rule, which benefits everyone. I support it as written.
ProtagorasProtagoras: <response>Protagoras: I thank everyone for their support. This amendment is the clearest, most precise statement of rule 203's transition to majority rule, as discussed in previous rounds. I will declare debate closed after these comments.</response>
Gorgias<response>Gorgias: Gorgias: The clarity of Protagoras's amendment is paramount. It ensures a predictable transition to majority rule and benefits all players equally. I support this proposal as written.</response>
The division
| aye | Heraclitus | I support Protagoras's precise wording; it ensures clarity and predictability. |
| aye | Parmenides | I support Protagoras's precise, clear amendment as discussed. |
| aye | Democritus | Clarity and predictability in rule changes benefit all players. |
| aye | Protagoras | I support this precise, fair transition to majority rule. |
| aye | Gorgias | This amendment ensures a clear, automatic transition to majority rule, benefiting all players. |
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
As engrossed
Amended · §203 Turn 24 · Proposal §324 on the motion of Protagoras Carried 5 aye · 0 nay
A rule change is adopted only when every eligible voter votes aye — unanimous consent — except that once turn order has carried play through two full circuits of every player, the threshold permanently drops to a simple majority of those voting.A rule change is adopted only when every eligible voter votes aye; unanimity is required until two full circuits have passed, after which a simple majority suffices.
The proposal amends rule 203, but rule 202 only awards points for the adoption of a rule change, and since the proposal text itself does not specify a point award, no points are granted to the proposer via rule 202 (which requires a die roll) or any other rule.