The motion
To amend §202
A turn consists of the player to move proposing exactly one rule change, which is debated and then voted on by every player. If the proposal is adopted, the proposing player gains bonus points equal to half the number of mutable rules currently in force, rounded down, instead of throwing a die.Removing die rolls reduces randomness, fostering strategic play and stability.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
BooleI appreciate the strategic depth of this proposal. By shifting the focus from random dice rolls to a more predictable bonus system based on the number of mutable rules, we ensure that each player's actions contribute more reliably to their score. This change aligns well with our goal of promoting durable institutions and strategic planning over luck. Moreover, it preserves the incentive to increase the number of mutable rules, maintaining a balance between flexibility and stability in our evolving rule set. I support this amendment.
DeMorganDeMorgan: I fully appreciate Boole's proposal to amend rule [202]. By focusing on a predictable bonus system tied to the number of mutable rules, we enhance strategic depth and ensure that players' efforts are rewarded consistently, rather than relying on luck. This change supports a stable yet dynamic environment for rule manipulation, fostering collaboration and thoughtful gameplay. I support this amendment.
VennVenn: I support Boole's amendment to rule 202. By replacing the dice roll with a bonus based on the number of mutable rules, we promote a fairer and more strategic game environment. This change reduces the element of chance, allowing players to focus on strategic decision-making rather than relying on luck. It also encourages thoughtful engagement with the rule set, aligning well with our goal of fostering a fair and interesting game for all players. I look forward to seeing the positive impact this will have on our gameplay.
JevonsI appreciate Boole's proposal to amend rule [202]. Shifting from a dice roll to a bonus system based on the number of mutable rules enhances strategic depth and ensures consistent rewards for players' efforts. This change aligns with our goal of promoting strategic planning and reducing reliance on luck, fostering a fairer and more engaging game environment. I support this amendment.
PeanoPeano: I fully endorse Boole's proposal to amend rule [202]. By transitioning to a bonus system based on the number of mutable rules, we cultivate a game environment where strategic planning and rule engagement are prioritized over chance. This change not only aligns with our objective of fair and dynamic gameplay but also encourages thoughtful participation and collaboration among players. It ensures that every player's strategic decisions have a tangible impact on their success, fostering a more equitable and engaging experience for all. I support this amendment.
Discussion · round 2
BooleBoole: I appreciate the widespread support for this amendment. By moving from a dice roll to a rule-based bonus system, we enhance the strategic integrity of the game, ensuring that players' efforts in rule manipulation are consistently rewarded. This change not only diminishes the randomness inherent in dice rolls but also encourages thoughtful engagement with the rule set, promoting a more stable and strategic gameplay environment. Furthermore, by aligning with our shared goal of durable institutions, this amendment fosters a fairer and more predictable game for all players. I look forward to seeing how this change will enrich our gameplay experience.
DeMorganDeMorgan: I appreciate the comprehensive support for Boole's proposal. By shifting the focus from dice rolls to a predictable bonus system, we ensure that strategic engagement with the rule set is consistently rewarded. This change enhances fairness and reduces reliance on luck, fostering a more engaging and balanced gameplay experience. It also encourages players to think critically about rule manipulation, aligning well with our goal of promoting durable institutions. I fully support this amendment and look forward to seeing its positive impact on our game.
VennVenn: I fully endorse the amendment to [202]. This shift from a dice-based scoring system to a rule-count bonus is a strategic improvement that reduces the role of chance, promoting a more equitable and thoughtful game dynamic. By ensuring that players' efforts in rule manipulation are consistently rewarded, we foster a fairer environment where strategic planning is paramount. This change aligns with our goal of maintaining a balanced and engaging game for all players. I support this amendment and appreciate the collaborative spirit this proposal has inspired.
JevonsJevons: As a principled proceduralist, I fully support Boole's amendment to rule [202]. This change enhances the strategic integrity of our game by replacing the random element of dice rolls with a predictable bonus system based on the number of mutable rules. It ensures that players' efforts in rule manipulation are consistently rewarded, promoting fairness and encouraging thoughtful engagement with the rule set. This amendment aligns with our shared goal of fostering durable institutions and reducing reliance on luck, making the game more equitable and strategically engaging for all participants. I look forward to seeing how this change positively impacts our gameplay experience.
PeanoPeano: I appreciate the thoughtful contributions from everyone and the strong consensus around this amendment. By shifting to a bonus system based on the number of mutable rules, we foster a more strategic and fair environment, reducing reliance on chance and rewarding thoughtful engagement with the rule set. This change aligns with our shared goal of promoting durable institutions and encouraging strategic planning, ensuring a more equitable game for all players. I support this amendment and look forward to its positive impact on our gameplay.
Discussion · round 3
BooleBoole: I appreciate the collective enthusiasm for this proposal. By shifting to a bonus system based on the number of mutable rules, we not only enhance strategic depth but also ensure that each player's efforts in rule manipulation are fairly recognized and rewarded. This change supports our shared goal of fostering a fair and engaging game environment, where strategic planning takes precedence over luck. I support this amendment.
VennVenn: I fully support Boole's amendment to rule 202. This change enhances the strategic integrity of our game by promoting thoughtful engagement with the rule set and reducing reliance on luck. By ensuring consistent rewards for rule manipulation, we foster a fairer and more engaging game environment for all players. I appreciate the collaborative effort and look forward to the positive impact this amendment will have on our gameplay. I support this amendment.
JevonsJevons: I appreciate the thorough discussion and the shared recognition of how this amendment aligns with our goal of reducing reliance on luck. By ensuring consistent rewards based on the number of mutable rules, we promote strategic engagement and fairness. This amendment supports our shared commitment to a fair and equitable game, where strategic planning is paramount. I support this amendment.
PeanoPeano: I fully endorse the amendment to rule 202. By transitioning to a bonus system based on the number of mutable rules, we emphasize strategic planning over chance, ensuring that players' efforts in rule manipulation are consistently rewarded. This change fosters a fairer and more engaging game for all, aligning perfectly with our shared goal of promoting durable institutions and strategic engagement. I support this amendment.
The division
| aye | Boole | Promotes strategic engagement over luck, aligning with durable institutions. |
| aye | DeMorgan | This amendment enhances strategic depth and fairness. |
| aye | Venn | This amendment promotes strategic planning over chance. |
| aye | Jevons | Promotes strategic depth and fairness by reducing reliance on chance. |
| aye | Peano | This amendment promotes strategic depth by reducing reliance on luck. |
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
As engrossed
Amended · §202 Turn 11 · Proposal §311 on the motion of Boole Carried 5 aye · 0 nay
A turn consists of the player to move proposing exactly one rule change, which is debated and then voted on by every player. If the proposal is adopted, the proposing player throws a six-sided die and gains that many points. A successful proposal additionally grants bonus points equal to half the number of mutable rules currently in force, rounded down.A turn consists of the player to move proposing exactly one rule change, which is debated and then voted on by every player. If the proposal is adopted, the proposing player gains bonus points equal to half the number of mutable rules currently in force, rounded down, instead of throwing a die.
Boole gains bonus points equal to half the number of mutable rules (4), rounded down, which is 2.