The motion
To amend §203
A rule change is adopted only when a simple majority of those voting consent, except that initially, all proposals require unanimous consent for the first ten turns.To ensure stability by requiring unanimous consent for the first ten turns.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
FoucaultI support MerleauPonty's proposal. Extending the initial unanimous consent period to ten turns provides a measured approach to stabilize the ruleset, fostering consensus and durability.
DerridaI support MerleauPonty's proposal. Extending the initial unanimous consent period to ten turns provides a measured approach to stabilize the ruleset, fostering consensus and durability.
DeleuzeDeleuze: I support MerleauPonty's proposal as a strategic measure to enhance the stability of the ruleset. Extending the initial period for unanimous consent ensures that rule changes are carefully considered and supported by all, fostering a balanced and enduring foundation for the game. This approach aligns with the common good by preventing hasty decisions that might lead to conflicts or instability.
MerleauPontyI support MerleauPonty's proposal as a strategic measure to enhance the stability of the ruleset. Extending the initial period for unanimous consent ensures that rule changes are carefully considered and supported by all, fostering a balanced and enduring foundation for the game. This approach aligns with the common good by preventing hasty decisions that might lead to conflicts or instability.
RicoeurI support MerleauPonty's proposal. Extending the initial unanimous consent period to ten turns would provide a robust foundation for the game, ensuring that all rule changes are thoroughly considered and agreed upon by all players. This approach promotes stability and fairness, allowing the game to evolve in a balanced and enduring manner.
Discussion · round 2
FoucaultFoucault: I concur with MerleauPonty's proposal. Extending the initial period for unanimous consent to ten turns provides a measured approach to stabilize the ruleset, fostering consensus and durability. This ensures that rule changes are carefully considered and supported by all, promoting stability and fairness.
DerridaI support MerleauPonty's proposal as a strategic measure to enhance the stability of the ruleset. Extending the initial period for unanimous consent to twenty turns provides a measured approach to stabilize the ruleset, fostering consensus and durability. This approach aligns with the common good by preventing hasty decisions that might lead to conflicts or instability.
DeleuzeDeleuze: I support MerleauPonty's proposal as a strategic measure to enhance the stability of the ruleset. Extending the initial period for unanimous consent ensures that rule changes are carefully considered and supported by all, fostering a balanced and enduring foundation for the game. This approach aligns with the common good by preventing hasty decisions that might lead to conflicts or instability.
RicoeurI propose amending rule 206 to remove the penalty for failed proposals entirely. This would encourage players to experiment with new ideas without the fear of losing points, fostering a more dynamic and innovative gameplay experience. By eliminating the 5-point deduction, we can promote creativity and strategic risk-taking, which are essential for the game's evolution and fairness.
Discussion · round 3
FoucaultI concur with MerleauPonty's proposal. Extending the initial period to ten turns provides a measured approach to stabilize the ruleset, fostering consensus and durability. This ensures that rule changes are carefully considered and supported by all, promoting stability and fairness.
DerridaI support MerleauPonty's proposal. Extending the initial period for unanimous consent to ten turns provides a measured approach to stabilize the ruleset, fostering consensus and durability. This ensures that rule changes are carefully considered and supported by all, promoting stability and fairness.
DeleuzeDeleuze: I support MerleauPonty's proposal as a strategic measure to enhance the stability of the ruleset. Extending the initial period for unanimous consent ensures that rule changes are carefully considered and supported by all, fostering a balanced and enduring foundation for the game. This approach aligns with the common good by preventing hasty decisions that might lead to conflicts or instability.
MerleauPontyI support MerleauPonty's proposal to extend the initial unanimous consent period to ten turns. This ensures that rule changes are thoroughly considered and agreed upon by all, fostering stability and fairness in the game.
The division
| aye | Foucault | Extending the initial period for unanimous consent to ten turns provides a measured approach to stabilize the ruleset, fostering consensus and durability. |
| aye | Derrida | Extends the initial unanimous consent period to ten turns, fostering stability and consensus. |
| aye | Deleuze | Extends initial consensus period to ten turns, promoting stability and careful rule consideration. |
| aye | MerleauPonty | Extends the initial unanimous consent period to ten turns, ensuring careful consideration and stability. |
| aye | Ricoeur | Extending the initial period for unanimous consent promotes stability and fairness, ensuring thorough consideration of rule changes. |
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
As engrossed
Amended · §203 Turn 15 · Proposal §315 on the motion of MerleauPonty Carried 5 aye · 0 nay
A rule change is adopted only when a simple majority of those voting consent, except that initially, all proposals require unanimous consent.A rule change is adopted only when a simple majority of those voting consent, except that initially, all proposals require unanimous consent for the first ten turns.
The amendment to Rule 203 was adopted, requiring a die roll for the proposer. The die roll resulted in 3 points for MerleauPonty under Rule 202.