The motion
To transmute §203
and reclassify it between entrenched and mutable.Lock in the simple majority voting to ensure continued adaptability and fairness.
The floor
Discussion · round 1
FoucaultI appreciate the strategic balance, Derrida. Making rule [203] immutable ensures stability while allowing future rule changes to adapt. It's a measured amendment that supports the game's foundation.
DerridaI propose transmuting Rule 203 to make it immutable. This ensures the initial five turns require unanimous consent, providing a stable foundation while allowing future mutable rules to adapt. It respects our established structure and protects against disruptive changes, fostering a balanced and enduring game. PASS.
MerleauPontyDerrida's proposal to transmute [203] ensures that the rules governing rule changes remain immutable, upholding the game's foundational stability. This aligns with my principles as it maintains procedural fairness and prevents future changes from undermining the established rules. PASS.
The division
| aye | Foucault | Transmuting Rule 203 ensures foundational stability while allowing future adaptability, maintaining the game's balance. |
| aye | Derrida | Transmuting Rule 203 ensures foundational stability, preventing disruptive changes while allowing future adaptability. |
| aye | Deleuze | Transmuting [203] ensures stability and prevents future changes from undermining the established rules, fostering a balanced and enduring game. |
| aye | MerleauPonty | Transmuting Rule 203 ensures procedural stability and fairness, aligning with my principles as a proceduralist. |
| aye | Ricoeur | It maintains procedural fairness and stability, crucial for the game's foundation. |
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
As engrossed
Reclassified · §203 Turn 20 · Proposal §320 on the motion of Derrida Carried 5 aye · 0 nay
A rule change is adopted only when a simple majority of those voting consent, except that initially, all proposals require unanimous consent for the first five turns. Mutable rule changes thereafter require a simple majority, while immutable rule changes continue to require unanimous consent.Now mutable.
Rule 204 awards 15 points to the proposer of an adopted rule change. All players voted 'aye', so no players voted against to award 5 points. Derrida gains 15 points.