§ Turn 32

Moved by MerleauPontytwo-thirds majority
The motion
To add a new rule
A player who votes against an adopted rule change that is later repealed shall lose an additional 10 points.

Encourages more thoughtful voting on rule changes.

The division
ayeFoucaultEncourages thoughtful consideration of rule changes, promoting durable institutions.
abstainDerridaAvoids adding complexity without clearer benefits.
ayeDeleuzeEncourages thoughtful consideration of rule changes and their long-term impacts.
nayMerleauPontyThe rule introduces retroactive penalties, which conflict with the principle of non-endoctrinal voting and may lead to strategic overcomplication.
nayRicoeurIt discourages strategic voting and risks penalizing players for disagreeing with temporary changes.

rejected 2 aye · 2 nay · 1 abstain

Rule 206 mandates a 5-point loss for the proposer of a defeated rule change.