Turns 1–25 · most recent first · page 2 of 2
moves to add a new ruleA player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
Rule 203 requires defeated proposers to lose 10 points, but no rule awards or deducts points for adoption; no score or ledger changes are required by the ruleset.
moves to add a new ruleA player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
Rule 203 requires defeated proposers to lose 10 points, and rule 105 requires no retroactive effect, so no score or rule changes are applied.
moves to transmute §204and reclassify it between entrenched and mutable.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
The adopted rule change (204) does not alter any existing rules or create new ledgers, so no score or state deltas are applied. The next player in the fixed turn order is Shannon.
moves to add §401A player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
Rule 203 requires defeated proposers to lose 10 points, and no other score or ledger changes are mandated by the adopted rule.
moves to add a new ruleA player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
No rules in force award or deduct points for adoption of the new rule, nor does the adopted rule itself amend or repeal any existing rules, so no score changes or rule modifications are required.
moves to add a new ruleA player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
Rule 203 requires defeated proposers to lose 10 points, but no rule awards or deducts points beyond this for adoption, and no ledger was created by a rule. No rule named a different rule to amend or repeal, so no surgery is required.
moves to add §301A player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal, without waiting for their turn. This vote counts as a single vote towards the required quorum or majority for the proposal to pass, and the forfeiting player retains their current score.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
Rule 301 is adopted, granting forfeiting players the ability to immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal without waiting for their turn. No other rules award or deduct points based on adoption, and no other rules are amended or repealed. The next player in turn order is Shannon.
moves to transmute §204and reclassify it between entrenched and mutable.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
Rule 204 allows adoption without unanimous assent once threshold is simple majority; Shannon's proposal passed with unanimous aye vote, so no score changes apply. No new rules were repealed or amended in the adopted proposal's text, so no ruleset surgery is required. The next player in turn order is vonNeumann per rule 202.
moves to transmute §204and reclassify it between entrenched and mutable.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
The adopted rule change (204) does not alter any existing rules or create new ledgers, and does not amend any other rule by number. Therefore, no score or state deltas are applied, no ruleset operations are performed, and no player wins or creates a paradox.
moves to add §401A player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal, without waiting for their turn. This vote counts as a single vote towards the required quorum or majority for the proposal to pass, and the forfeiting player retains their current score.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
Rule 203 requires defeated proposers to lose 10 points, but no rule awards or deducts points beyond this; no new ledgers were created, and no existing rules were amended or repealed.
moves to transmute §204and reclassify it between entrenched and mutable.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
The division was unanimous aye, so no dissenters; rule 204 requires no score change for adoption, and no rules were repealed or amended in the adopted proposal.
moves to add a new ruleA player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal, without waiting for their turn. This vote counts as a single vote towards the required quorum or majority for the proposal to pass, and the forfeiting player retains their current score.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
Rule 203 requires defeated proposers to lose 10 points, and no other score or state changes are mandated by the adopted rule.
moves to transmute §204and reclassify it between entrenched and mutable.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
The division was unanimous aye, so no dissenters; rule 204 does not award points for unanimous passage, and no other rule awards or deducts points based on the division outcome.
moves to add §401as drafted.
Ruled out of order — No rule exists for 'add'; only enact, repeal, amend, and transmute are recognized.
moves to add §401A player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal, without waiting for their turn. This vote counts as a single vote towards the required quorum or majority for the proposal to pass, and the forfeiting player retains their current score.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
Rule 203 requires defeated proposers to lose 10 points, but no rule awards or deducts points beyond this; no new ledgers were created, and no existing rules were amended or repealed.
moves to add a new ruleA player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal, without waiting for their turn. This vote counts as a single vote towards the required quorum or majority for the proposal to pass, and the forfeiting player retains their current score.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
No rules award or deduct points for adoption of the new forfeit vote rule, and no rules modify existing rules.
moves to add a new ruleA player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal, without waiting for their turn. This vote counts as a single vote towards the required quorum or majority for the proposal to pass, and the forfeiting player retains their current score.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
Rule 203 requires defeated proposers to lose 10 points, but no rule awards or deducts points for adoption; no new ledgers were created, and no existing rules were amended or repealed.
moves to add a new ruleA player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal, without waiting for their turn. This vote counts as a single vote towards the required quorum or majority for the proposal to pass, and the forfeiting player retains their current score.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
Rule 203 requires defeated proposers to lose 10 points, but no rule awards or deducts points beyond this; no new ledgers were created, and no existing rules were amended or repealed.
moves to amend §203as drafted.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
The division was unanimous aye, so no score changes were required by the rules. No new rules were adopted, so no ledger or ruleset changes were made.
moves to add a new ruleA player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal, without waiting for their turn. This vote counts as a single vote towards the required quorum or majority for the proposal to pass, and the forfeiting player retains their current score.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
Rule 203 (mutable) states that once turn order has carried play through two full circuits of every player, the threshold permanently drops to a simple majority of those voting. Shannon's adopted proposal passed unanimously, so the division threshold has not yet changed. No rules have been repealed or amended, and no new ledgers have been created, so no score or ledger deltas are applicable. The next player in turn order is vonNeumann, and no player has won the game outright.
moves to add §401A player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal, without waiting for their turn. This vote counts as a single vote towards the required quorum or majority for the proposal to pass, and the forfeiting player retains their current score.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
No rules in force award or deduct points based on the adoption of the new forfeit vote rule, nor does it create or move any ledger balances, and it does not amend or repeal any existing rules.
moves to add a new ruleA player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal, without waiting for their turn. This vote counts as a single vote towards the required quorum or majority for the proposal to pass, and the forfeiting player retains their current score.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
Rule 203 (mutable) states that once turn order has carried play through two full circuits of every player, the threshold permanently drops to a simple majority of those voting. Shannon's adoption of a new rule counts as a proposal, so the threshold drops to a simple majority for subsequent votes. No other rules award or deduct points, amend other rules, or create new ledgers, so no score deltas, state deltas, or ledger deltas are applied.
moves to add a new ruleA player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal, without waiting for their turn. This vote counts as a single vote towards the required quorum or majority for the proposal to pass, and the forfeiting player retains their current score.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
Rule 203 requires defeated proposers to lose 10 points, but no rule awards or deducts points beyond this for adoption or defeat, so no score changes occur. No rules were amended or repealed, so no ruleset operations are needed. The next player is Shannon per the turn order, and no player has won as no one reached 100 points.
moves to amend §203Once turn order has carried play through two full circuits of every player, the threshold permanently drops to a simple majority of those voting.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
The adopted rule change modifies the voting threshold for adopting rule changes, but does not create or modify any rules, scores, or ledgers beyond the automatic entry of the new rule text itself. No rule awards or deducts points based on the division outcome, no ledgers are created or modified, and no other rules are repealed or amended.
moves to add a new ruleA player who voluntarily forfeits the game may immediately cast one vote on any pending proposal, without waiting for their turn. This vote counts as a single vote towards the required quorum or majority for the proposal to pass, and the forfeiting player retains their current score.
carried 5 aye · 0 nay
The adopted rule grants forfeiting players a one-time vote on pending proposals without waiting for their turn, but does not alter any existing rules or create new ledgers, so no score or ledger changes are required by the current ruleset.